Click Here!

Reviews for Tithen dulin

By : Mystkyten
  • From ANON - Cait on April 08, 2004
    I think it would be adorable for Legolas and Tithen to hook up but if it doesn't work out Haldir would be great. I leave the decision in your hands. Whatever it may be, I'm sure it will be magnificent.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yue on April 08, 2004
    ohh haldir would be nice but i dont want him to die of a broken heart. having her pair up with legolas is just plain weird at this point so i op haldir or a decendent of a well known ranger aragorn might know. something like that. well i hope thats helpful and see ya soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on April 07, 2004
    First my condolences on your crash. We just updated our whole system and I lost a lot of things I didn't think would be affected. I will never be able to get them back even though I had been careful to save. I don't understand computers enough to know why only that they are lost to cyberspace.

    I would like for Tithen Duilin to have a human love interest. I think it would be really interesting to see Legolas and Thranduil have a human girl child grow up, marry, have children and then die in the fullness of time. Then have an interest in her offspring down through the generations. Maybe someone from Rohan or Laketown, Esgaroth or a woodsman that lives on the edges of the Greenwood. I think there are some men there and also there are some in the Iron Hills. I'm not terribly interested in elf/human relationships. I just feel that there are only the Peredhils in Imladris and then Arwen/Aragorn, Luthien/Beren. I do know that there area few others though. I don't think it is that usual for an elf and a human to mate. Just the lifespan thing would preclude it. I think the elf left behind would fade or go to the West to avoid fading. And what about the children. The Valar made a special dispensation for Elrond and his brother because of the deeds of their parents. No one else would be likely to get one for their children.

    No matter what you decide I will read till the end, bitter or not. Thanks for asking. giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Brin on April 07, 2004
    I've liked your story and if you're going to cont
    it then Haldir is a good thought or perhaps one
    or both of the twins?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Teri on April 07, 2004
    Yeah! Glad to see you back again. You ask good questions. I think we all know Tithen will be raised by a King and raised as in a royal environment but we all know she is human. Somehow I see Tithen not with a human but with an elf and given special consideration by the Valar for some kind of elven type heroism so she can become immortal. Frankly, I see her becoming quite the energetic, somewhat untamed young woman who can only be mastered by someone with a sense of humor - Rumil, Haldir's younger brother. I think it could be quite challng ang and funny as well as dramatic. Just a thought. I'll take anything you write.
    Take care,
    Teri

    Report Review

  • From ANON - kirameki on January 06, 2004
    That was so adorable! I enjoyed reading it very much. The only problem I saw was that Legolas' sister had black hair, which I think would have been unlikely due to the kind of elf she would have been. But since this is a fan fic anything goes. |^_^| Besides I may have my info wrong.
    And I also liked how you portrayed Legolas' dad. A great aged warrior and ruler who has a bit of a gruph side, but is a pretty cool guy aside from his hot temper. I wouldn't mind a sequel, if there isn't one yet.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - JastaElf on December 20, 2003
    Hi Mystkyten!! I'm glad you have recovered the the worst of your asthma--I had not known you had been ill! Sorry to hear that, but I hope you are better now.

    I wanted to leave a review and tell you I am very pleased with the way your story turned out. Wbeaubeautiful resolution for everyone--except the bad Elf, of course... though ehe ghe gets to go to Mandos now and make reparation for what he has done, so maybe in the end even he will know redemption. :-)

    Thank you for showing us why Thranduil was such a hardcase, and what exactly it was that made him that way. It was good to see him realize he had been wrong, and that if he did not take definitive action there would be another great loss; no child should have to suffer that way!

    I'm glad now that Tithen Dulin will have a home, and be safe; that though her life will be shorter than those of the Elves who now care for her, she will nevertheless have a place to live, people to love her, and things to do for the rest of her life. Heaven knows it won't be unexciting!

    I would like to see a sequel that takes place many years from now, when Tithen Dulin is old. Has she had some sort of love affair in her life maybe? Fallen in love with one of Thranduil's warriors, and is the mother of Half-elven children who will remember her many years from now? Maybe it is nearing the end of her life, and Legolas's departed older sister comes to bear her spirit home? (since of course Tolkien tells us that humans AND Elves go to Mandos, but the Human spirits go to a different part of the Halls when they die...) Could be a lovely tear-jerker! :-)

    Maybe Thranduil is there with her when she dies, and senses again the spirit of his daughter... and maybe his wife too?

    Anyway, I'm sure whatever you decide to do will be lovely! Thank you for an exciting and sweet story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Debbie on December 19, 2003

    Hiya! I would like a sequal of the girl and Legolas to be together, by the way great fic. see ya
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on December 18, 2003
    Well T and L are going to the rescue. That is good.
    They get waylaid by spiders. That is bad.
    Legolas gets stabbed in the side. That is very bad.
    The crazy elf is now going to hurt Thranduil. That is very bad also.
    And we still have tithen dulin in a cave tied up and terrified. That is also very bad.
    We are at a critical point for all these characters. They are up to their eyeballs in badness.
    Get them out of there please!!! giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tella on December 10, 2003
    Your story has been nominated for the Slcatecategory of the MPA awards.
    I would like your permission to link to this story on your website or at FF.net so the readers can vote on it. :)
    Thanks, I've included some of the MPA information for you below. :)

    Nominations are being accepted only until Dec 19th. Voting begins Dec 20th and runs until January 5th at which point the awards ceremonies will be held in my yahoo group on a date still to be announced.

    you can visit the yahoo hosting group at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ElvenLords/

    this is also the most stable location for the MPA library (located in the Files section in the LOTR fanfiction library folder)

    or, visit the library directly http://www.geocities.com/bastet_1999/Elven_Lords_Website/mpa.htm
    but bandwidth is mimited at this site.

    You can also access all the librariesincluding the MPA at my webpage http://www.geocities.com/bastet_1999/
    but once again, this is the same location as the above MPA library url so bandwidth is limited. :)

    Please contact me as soon as possible regarding your nomination so that I may update the library well enough ahead of the end date as possible.

    thank you so much,

    (`'•.¸(`'•.¸ ¸.•'´) ¸.•'´)
    «´¨ *Tella* ¨`» bastet@telusplanet.net
    (¸.•'´(¸.•'´ `'•.¸)`' •.¸)
    ¸.•´
    ( `•.¸
    `•.¸ )
    ¸.•)´
    (.•´
    `*.
    *.


    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on December 07, 2003
    Even if the elf is a nut case he is still a bad elf and deserves whatevergetsgets. Scaring a poor little girl that way. Well anyway it is now Legolas and Thranduil to the rescue. And they better hurry up too. giggle
    Report Review

  • From sivan325 on December 07, 2003
    This is good chapter, please update soon.

    I stil love what I read.

    Sivan
    Report Review

  • From ANON - le_obe_oblique on December 07, 2003
    scary! good with l and t though. looking forward to next chapter. hope that you are feeling better. asmha is so so annoying. had it as a kid. my mum and brother have it really serverly though so i can commiserate


    huggs
    louise
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Debbie on December 07, 2003
    Hi, just wanna say great fic can't wait for another update, please update soon, see ya
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Brin on December 07, 2003
    As much as I want to read the next chapters,
    please don't over work & tire yourself. In the mean
    time, get well while I wonder what will happen next.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!