Click Here!

Reviews for Greenleaf & Imladris 13 - The Choices We Must Make

By : MPB
  • From ANON - Jayn on June 03, 2005
    HOW KUTE!! I'm glad their together but i feel really bad for Elrohir, and Legolas in a way. Well, I wouldn't know true love if it came and bit my in the @$$... I'm one of those people who can't tell it in others of my self. If they like me, tell me or I'll never know... Lol. Meep, tangent.

    I'm only on 13? But theres so many!! I wanna see them together!! but i love how they get together. Its more real then two or three sentences on how time passed. Lol. Your a very dedicated author. Wish i was like that... ^_^
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kirameki on January 08, 2004
    That was so sweet! Go Elladan. As for Elrohir and Legolas, on the other hand.... |-_-;| Stupid Legolas, he's so clueless. I feel so sorry for Elrohir. *shakes Legolas* Wake up you idiot! And as for Melthoron, oh that was hilarious. Only the twins would dare such a thing. Not that he didnesereserve it... Let's see, so now they've bedded half the royal family. |^_^| This is just too much. Anyways, that's all. I'm hard pressed when writing all these reviews for you, seeing as there are only so many times you can tell a person of their brilliance. I figure you know by now my standing on the series, after all I've read the entire thing thus far. |^_^| I hope it doesn't take too much longer for Legolas and Elrohir to get together. Elrohir's situation is so heart wrenching.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lupusdragon on January 07, 2004
    For one so intelligent, Legolas is exceedi nai naive. While that can be endearing, it is much more frustrating. I am with Elladan in this, the Wood-elf is afraid of his feelings, afraid of being hurt by love that he cannot see his feelings for what they are. It is unfortunate that he would cause his friend such pain by withholding his heart. It should be obvious to both how much each loves the other, but they are blinded by their fears and pessimism. I would like to shake some sense into the both of them. Perhaps Nimei wil will succeed in making Legolas see reason.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Deathangelgw on January 07, 2004
    I have been keeping up with this delicious tale now for about four months and dorkus me has not reviewed it at all!! Shame on me!! No wait, yes I did!! I begged for more!

    Well guess what...I have been faithfully reading it and now I am BEGGING for more!! Gah...I can't stand the inbetween waits between this glorious piece of art's chapters!! I long for more...neeeeeed more...am begging for more!!

    Such wonderful stuff! Oh my the suspense, the tragedy, the heartache, the lemon...oh my and the teasing! Good god I loved how the twins got back at the oldest brother (not even attempting to remember the name...) And then the sweet declaration between Elladan and Nimethiel! Oh so wonderful! And then I just want to hit clueless Legolas...GAH who would turn down such a wonderful Elf as Elrohir!?

    ANYWAYS, enough ranting...though I am sure your ego is up by now...I love this and I doooooooo so want some more soon!!

    Love, DA
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Pervy Elf on January 07, 2004
    Every chapter you update with gets better and better, and continues to leave me wishing for more!
    Those Peredhil twins and Legolas can be quite stubborn, no? As I continue to read, I find myself relating more often then not with Elrohir's predicament. To know that love is so close, but thought not returned is a horrible thing. And that conection with your story lets me enjoy the angst just that much more.
    I can't say enough great things about your story that haven't already been said. Update soon, for I will be waiting!


    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kryspen on January 06, 2004
    *sigh* am having to skip over the Elladan/OFC parts ^_^ but have enjoyed reading the rest!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Jayla on January 06, 2004
    I have been enjoying your stories so much. You put so much depth of character and feeling into your stories. I am so impatient for Legolas to finally realize his feelings for Elrohir and yet I am loath to reach the end of the story. You really are quite talented at weaving a tale!! Thankyou also for being so prompt at updating.
    Jayla
    Report Review

  • From ANON - louise_oblique on January 06, 2004
    fab and looking forward to the next huggs louise

    srry short uni exam this afternoon
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anita H. on January 05, 2004
    Sorry I did not review sooner, but I am in Toronto right now for my 8 week clinical placement. I flew at fryday and this is the first day at school! Very exciting for someonw who has never been out of Europe :)

    Anyway, this is very sad for Elrohir. I am not sure I could deal with that. I don't know why Legolas doesn't see what he is doing to his best friend. Only time will tell.

    Continue quickly!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MJLuvsPolar on January 04, 2004
    I stand by my previous assertion: Legolas IS jealous indeed if he feels uncomfortable about the idea of Elrohir being with another Ellith! It's so distressing that Elrohir doesn't seem to recognize this. Eë hië his confession to Elladan was just heartbreaking, due to large measure (for me anyway) because it was so restrained, so *warrior* like. I loved it when he told Elladan that he didn’t want even his pity. Now I’m worried though. What Elladan says about leaving Middle Earth for Valinor makes sense; after all their errantry the peace of Valinor may not hold much appeal. Elrohir has told Legolas that love is what he feels would sway him to choose immortality but I fear love is also what could make him choose to remain in Middle Earth as a mortal: would you want to watch your hearts love marry another? Surely he *must* be thinking that although Legolas has vowed not to give his heart to another, Valinor may change that resolve.

    I’ve also been wondering what Legolas' reaction would be should Elrohir choose not to sail? I have the strangest feeling that he would fade. Obviously he didn't when his mother died, but he had Elrohir to help him then didn't he? And we are taking about his ‘heart’s brother’. Ok I know this is all speculation but the fact that I am thinking such dark thoughts means that for me you have truly captured the heartbreak that is unrequited love because, right now, I *don't* get the feeling that all will be right in the end, which I find all the more amazincauscause I KNOW they get together.

    I know I'm neglecting Elladan and Nimeithel in this review - sorry 'bout that! I am certainly enjoying the progression of their relationship, I’m just enjoying being upset of Elrohir and Legolas more!

    Marie ;-)


    Report Review

  • From ANON - Gilraen on January 04, 2004
    Oh my dear Elrohir! The end almost made me cry! If you were to post all the chapters of this fic here i wouldnt move from the computer untill i had read them all!! I'm obsessed with it so please update as often as you are able to!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tux on January 04, 2004
    Oh, I hope they're not going to chose mortality! *Hopeful look at Eresse* They're not - are they?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - viewerv on January 04, 2004
    *sniff* Poor Elrohir.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Eresse on January 03, 2004
    Golodh is the Sindarin term for Noldo and Gelydh is its plural meaning Noldor. I always include a glossary at the bottom of each section any elvish s uss used in the story. Hope this helps you.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - question on January 03, 2004
    what does "Golodh" mean?
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!