Click Here!

Reviews for The Long Journey Home

By : silmfan
  • From ANON - WOOSTER on January 01, 2004
    WOW, keep on writing, please! I love this cold and enigmatic Erestor, and would love to read how Glorfindel is going to try to reach him and make him react. Like the bit about Elladan babling about Erestor, providing Glorfindel another piece to fit in an interesting puzzle. More, please!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Risika on January 01, 2004
    You have a good start on this. It looks promising. MORE PLEASE!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Eresse on December 31, 2003
    An intriguing introduction, clear and interesting characterizations, evocative descriptions and an engaging plot--please don't let this story end up unfinished (as you hinted in your header). Well-written tales are a rarity and therefore a joy and blessing to read. I think this is a real gem and hope you continue it to its conclusion. By the way, I think that using Glorfindel's thoughts as a means of furthering your story was very effective. That's one great thing about the written word. Storytelling isn't limited by the medium as it is, say, with a movie. In all, this promises to be well worth anyone's time. Do keep it up.

    regards,
    Eresse
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on December 31, 2003
    I love the thought of Glorfindel trying to get Mandos to put in plumbing so that everyone could soak in hot tubs.
    OOH! Poor elfling Elladan. He was even willing to lie for Glorfindel. No good really because I'm sure Erestor would take care that Elrond is kept up to date on all happenings.
    I thought Elladan's stream of conscience prattlings was very sweet. Glorfindel learned more about Erestor in thirty minutes from Elladan than he would have learned from the councilor in ten thousand years. Probably so.
    And chocolate. I wouldn't be able to live in middle earth unless they had chocolate. I realize it came from the New World (South America) but I am sure before the ending of the Age of Elves they had it in middle earth. That was probably Sauron's true plot. He wanted to corner the chocolate franchise for all middle earth. He deserved to go down.
    Well Glorfindel certainly is taking notice of Erestor so we know where this story is going. Goodie.
    Thank you for sharing and I look forward to more. giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Pookie on December 31, 2003
    *bounce*

    this story looks like it'll be really good!

    Although, personally, I have a hard time picturing Erestor as that... cold. So I hope he gets nicer throughout the story!

    I can't wair mor more!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Mirasaui on December 29, 2003
    Ah, I love it! Glorfindel is definitely the right Elf to breakthrough Erestor's frigid barrier.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on December 29, 2003
    I like a bouncy, happy carefree Glorfindel. He seems like he would be so much fun. Erestor on the other hand needs to lighten up. I take if for granted that the author will be taking care of this in time. The twins seem to be adorable. Looking forward to more. giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on December 28, 2003
    Oooo,Glorfindel/Erestor is getting to my second favorite pairing.I would love to read more please.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 28, 2003
    What an interesting beginning to your story with the formal arrival of Glorfindel to Imladris. Please continue it. I hope you will not lose interest later and will finish it.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - SailorPoison on December 28, 2003
    woohoo! I just plain love what you got so far. Esp how Glorfindel was reborn like that. It was so sad to see him die in the movie. Please keep up the t jot job! I hope you get many readers and many great reviews.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!