Adult-FanFiction.org : Lord of the Rings

Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name

By : Celesta

From ANON - sister kittty on January 08, 2004
This is most good.

Iam really enjoying it - drooling over the thought of a half/full naked Legolas and almost crying in sympathy with our dear Rose.

More...please?!
Report Review
From kirameki on January 08, 2004
Ah I knew I'd forget something...|-_-;| Just wanted to say, who, of the female populace anyhow, could possibly NOT forgive Leggie.
And extra note - I found myself severely wishing I was an elf since I had to go outside today in bitingly cold weather. As Asca says in chapter 1 "Lucky" and "It just wasn�t fair." I still can't get that scene of her piling snow on top of legolas' foot out of my head. Hmmm, maybe I should draw it. *nods head* Definitely worth considering...
Report Review
From kirameki on January 08, 2004
Lord help us all, Boromir is the first to pick up on the signs of their relationship?! *shrinks away* J/King but I do find it amusing. And, whoa... I didn't realize elves said words like dammnit... Well, I guess even they can get a bit ruffled... And I do hope you get to Legolis' princely heritage soon. I can just imagine her sa som something witty like "Fairy tale princes do exist. And to think I get one all to myself." Muahahahaha. Okay yeah that was a bit much, but I couldn't help myself |^_^|
Your story is very effecting, I found it difficult to read straight through at wat was very heart wrenching. I love angst, but you have a gift with comedy as well, which I have a feeling I will need more of, before this story is through. SO hurry with the next chapter.
As for e-mail correspondence, I'd love to, but word of warning... Once school starts I barely have time to read my e-mail let alone write it... |-_-;| Still, I'd be glad to help as much as I can. I'll e-mail you as soon as I get a chance.
And I agree, I just saw Pirates of the Carribean for the first time, after Christmas. It was totally awesome... And Orli was just as scruptious a pirate as he was an elf. *drool*
*has composed herself* Ahem, sorry about that. I sometimes let my fantasies get ahead of myself... especially when it concerns hot males, especially of elven persuasion. |^_~| Anyways, glad you like my reviews. I try to always review but only give long specific ones for those I really like. Or really dislike, though the latter is extremely rare. I think I've only ever given two bad reviews... |-_-| It was difficult, since I'm a nice person and hate to sound mean...
Now let's hope I haven't forgotten anything this time...

Report Review
From ANON - Elerrina Rose on January 07, 2004
ooohhhh... tension. The first shoe drops.
Poor Frodo. I just wanna squeeze him and make everything ok.
... And Legolas! Oh, sweet Elbereth! I can FEEL the mortification and self-loathing radiating from him. I wanna squeeze him too... but for entirely different reasons ;)
Good chapter, good chapter. Can't wait to see how this progresses.
~ Elerrina Rose

Report Review
From ANON - Cait on January 07, 2004
AWWWW! This is such a cute story. I love the idea of Legolas being an elven pillow. lol Update soon. Later
Report Review
From ANON - Elerrina Rose on January 07, 2004
I was pleasanthockhocked today to discover that you'd updated... AGAIN! well, hooray!
Glad that Bori and Asca got to talk. Awwww... she slept in a hobbit huddle. So cute :)
Also glad that Bori sees what's goin on btween Asca and her pillow (tee hee). So many fics complicate things with Boromir getting posessive right off the bat because she's human. At least if it DOES happen at one point, it will come from a bit closer to left field.
Still loving this!
~ Elerrina Rose
Report Review
From ANON - DragonEyeZ on January 07, 2004
Cute! :D I just started reading the story, but I have to say that in my opinion, this is not a "real" Mary-Sue. Some may claim it, but then again, they'd probably claim everything with someone coming from another world to be Mar Mary-Sue...
Anyway, before I start blabbering too much, I'd better tell you that I like the story. So, please, continue!
Report Review
From ANON - Risika on January 07, 2004
I'm still loving it! MORE!!!

Report Review
From kirameki on January 07, 2004
Ack, I keep forgetting things! Oh well. Just want to let you know, I totally understand you being in Med School. I'm not in Med, but majoring in Animation at an Art school which is probably just as time demanding, believe it or not. I'm still on vacation, but hafta go back soon. Waaah. I want more time off. And I'm also happy more chapters are already typed up. Means less wait time |^_^| heh heh.
Report Review
From kirameki on January 07, 2004
Oh, that was so sweet. And the hobbits were so kawaii! I just love Pippin. Not as much as las,las, but as Asca says, 'you get what you can aquire'. |^_~| Where are they going to find shoes for her. I mean, Legolas won't be able to hold onto her during their battle in Moria when they have to run, will he? Well, anyways, another great chapter. Can't wait for the next.
And, on another note, I'm glad you appreciated my comments. Just said what was on my mind. |^_^| "*sigh* great minds think alike� and then there�s us! " Gee howdya know? *grins*
Report Review
From ANON - AzureDragoness on January 06, 2004
Yup, Im still here. Med school? And you STILL manage to write anything?? Wow, are you some kind of god?????? XD Anyways, I like the play, especially since it reminds me of my friends and myself ^__^ Well, keep it up! Tis fluffy, yet not, and for once, the OC is SMART! And still not a Mary-Sue!!! *gasp*

Ok, bed-time for me... sleep deprivation is scary o__O
Report Review
From ANON - AzureDragoness on January 06, 2004
Well, I suppose I could feed da ego... *cautiously throws a few morsels to a tiny little thing* ^__^ Anywho, I'm still heeeeeeeere, and I aint going! Now update, so I have something to come home to besides the hell of school.
Report Review
From ANON - Elerrina Rose on January 06, 2004
oh, good. I'm glad they're off Carahdras. Yay Moria! At least the Balrog will keep her warm when she doesn't have her elf-pillow!
tee hee. I love Boromir and Haldir too, but part of loving those guys is accepting their ability to be stuck up pricks :) I can't wait for Hal to get his comuppance when he meets Asca. *les*les* I'm laughing already...
Keep the wonderfulness coming.
~ Elerrina Rose
Report Review
From ANON - kirameki on January 06, 2004
Oh, and 1 more thing! If you use any elvish, could you have the translation for it at the end of the chapter. I know a few words, but not much and it would be helpful. Thanks. *bows out*
Report Review
From ANON - kirameki on January 06, 2004
I'm really sorry to hear about you and your friends. I don't mind you incorporating it into the story at all. In fact it would be interesting to see Legolas' reaction to it. I personally, have fortunately never been through anything like that, though a relative of mine has (it was a long time ago so I was really little and don't know much about it). It's one of the things I hate the most, ya know. I think you writing about it might even help other's who have been through similar situations. That's my thought anyway. And your step-father really said something like that? What an ass. I do understand what it means to comfort a friend in pain, though he didn't go through something as horrible as rape, thankfully.
Now, onto the story...
Oh my lord, you did it again! This ust ust too much. But it's no fair, I want an Elven pillow, too, preferably shaped like Legolas. Think she'd mind if I stole him? |^_~| Legolas is such a doll. And when she started talking about a snuggle charm, heh heh heh. I can't wait for more! Don't make me wait too long! I like how you make her have this wit about her that I rarely see in LotR OCs. And I'm sure several of the things she says could be misconstrued by the fellowship. That could make things interesting.
Oh and I didn't mind her bitchin' out at Boromir. He had it comin, and I think he needed to be told off. The fellowship is way too tolerant sometimes... I don't hate him, but I'm not a huge fan. In fact I'm sure you've figured out my fave character by now, heh. It would've been awesome to see him and Asca go at it, so I'm sad to hear that they won't be. I hope they do a little at least though... Oh and what are you gonna do with Haldir!? I so pso picture it. Can't wait to see it. And I would like to see more interaction with the hobbits and Gimli. Yeah, that's about it for now. |^_^| Oh, and did I mention to hurry with the next chapter yet?
Report Review