Click Here!

Reviews for In Earendil's Light

By : AStrayn
  • From ANON - mistry89 on September 11, 2006
    Finished this a couple of days ago and felt I had to say Thank You. I enjoyed this story very much (am already lined up to read the rest of your stories), but thought I should comment here - this is where I was directed to find your stories, after all, and I'm very glad this was rec'd. On a simple level, it reinforces some of my own thoughts about Legolas, young (for an elf as presented in LOTR), and somehow pre-destined for the Fellowship, and also adds to the slashy side (why would such a relationship be actively encouraged by Thranduil and Elrond?), above and beyond these (very appealing) ideas, there is a sense of plot - a real tale. Your logic for the binding is wonderful, and doesn't feel as if it is either *too* unusual or *too* common. The character's dialogue was lovely and lyrical. I'm off to read more :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lioncourt on March 07, 2005
    Oh yeah, I forgot; The scene where Elrond first meet Legolas is adorable! Legolas was just too cute! I wanna eat him!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lioncourt on March 07, 2005
    This is absolutely brilliant. The characters and their feelings feels so real and true that I'm not sure if it's reality or fiction. Great!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on February 05, 2004
    Well of course we never doubted that thinguld uld turn out for both couples but of course we need to go through the whole process to enjoy it the most.
    You really let out all the stops for the penultimate loves scenes. You did great. They were very sweet, sensuous and satisfying. For the reader as well as the participants.
    Thank you for sharing this with us. It was a good read. giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kirameki on February 01, 2004
    Loving it, loving it. The relationship between Legolas & Elrohir you've built is simply breathtaking. Though it would nice if you provided translations for some of the elvish used at the bottom of your chapters. More please. |^_^|
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Teri on February 01, 2004
    Hello, I just started reading this fic. I read all 6 chapters today. Glorfindel has me so pissed off, I am barely able to stand it. His actions (or lack of action) toward Elladan is reprehensible. At the end of chapter 6, my heart was breaking and I cried like a baby. Please post the next chapter soon. I need to know that Glorfindel comes to his senses and saves Elladan. Please tell me everything will be okay. I'm so depressed though I am h tha that Elrohir and Legolas found their happiness. By the way, this is a great fic. Love your writing and hope you will continue.
    Take care,
    Teri

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nina on January 31, 2004
    Please, update soon. I want top see legolas/Elrohir binding and i'm also worried about Elladan.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Myro on January 31, 2004
    Thank you for the story. I know how many people hate deathfics but I feel this should be one. The ending would be the most effective and devastating to us readers.
    On a happier note I loved all the scenes with Erestor, he is such an underused character in LOTR.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on January 31, 2004
    Wow what an angst fest. I am so loving this. Very AU but great. Nicely written and very emotional.
    I had to laugh when Elrohir didn't know the captain was Legolas, "I have come to claim you," Prince of Mirkwood. Very nice reunion between the two of them. Elladan knew who the captain was. I guess Elrohir was just too tired and worried to realize.
    So the Woodland King was going to Romeo and Juliet Elrohir and Legolas. Not very nice.
    And Elladan is fading despite Erestor's best efforts. Sigh. I 'm glad that Elladan was awake for Glorfindel's confessions. So now after all that he feels his only comfort and peace will come from fading to the Hall of Waiting. He'll be all alone. Nana won't even be there. He does deserve some easing of his burden though.
    Elrohir and Legolas just couldn't wait any longer. Snicker. Lovely love scene beneath the willow and I think Adar will probably figure out something has changed.
    Elladan's little speach of reconciliation and acceptance was very nice. I know Glorfindel sees this as taming the wildness in Elladan and feels that ibad bad thing but it just shows Elladan's level of maturity now. He can now see beyond the mere physical and see love for what it really is. He may not agree, and I for one don't, but Glrofindel's feelings and attitudes must be understood and acknowledged whether agreed with or not. Glorfindel does love him very much just not in the way Elladan needs. Hopefully with losing Elladan a real possibility we can only hope that Glorfindel's feelings can change after all this time.
    They are now reconciled for the ceremony and until Elladan fades froief.ief. This will be interesting. I can't wait for an update but of course I have to. giggle

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nina on January 26, 2004
    Great chapter! Hope Ellandan and Glorfindel could be happy together and legolas/Elrohir are such a cute couple.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - louise_oblique on January 26, 2004
    Wove ove this fic, legolas very well done. wondering when G will get sorted out though

    huggs
    louise
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on January 26, 2004
    Legolas is a really fast learner isn't he? Elrohir certainly didn't seem to object. I think their love is very romantic aure.ure. What with all the diplomatic shenanigans going on I am sure you have some roadblocks for the future but the way you portray Elrohir and Legolas we know that love will win over all.
    As far as Glorfindel he needs really serious therapy. Elladan is a total mess emotionally and he just runs away. I guess whatever is going on is truly his problem and has little to do with Elladan. I love angst and watching the poor peredhil suffer.
    It was so clever to bring in about the twin knives even if they are movieverse and not bookverse. I will take both gladly.
    As far as Thranduil goes he is sure a nut case.
    Thanks for the update and can't wait for more angst. giggle
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Eresse on January 26, 2004
    Hi Gloromeien,
    Read the latest chapter and fell in love all over again with this story. It really feels like new. And it's just as enthralling and seductivethe the first time I read it. A real gem. Now if you'd only do something about that little reservation I had regarding Legolas later on... Sorry, that was simply more than I could resist after the lengthy discussion we had over just that one point! ;D

    Happy writing!
    Eresse
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kirameki on January 25, 2004
    Awww, that's cute. I love Elrohir/Legolas pairings. That last paragraph in chapter 4 was simply brilliant. But aiya, I wanna know what his answer was. |^_~|
    Report Review

  • From ANON - giggle on January 21, 2004
    I felt so sorry for Elladan. He must feel like the most unwanted in in Arda. Forty five years have passed! That is a long time to carry a torch for someone. I hope soon Glorfindel will either get over his dutiful feelings and love Elladan or at least tell him why.
    I think Elrohir and Legolas are really so sweet together. The thought of Elrond's face if he knew that Legolas had been kept untouched while his son is bedding every elf in sight was funny. At least Elrohir will know what he is doing on Legolas' majority night. I think it was fortuitous that the twins showed up.
    Thank you for the update. I am trying to catch up on reviewing since I have been sick and I looked forward to reading this again. giggle
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!