Click Here!

Reviews for Mani Marte? *complete*

By : bluegold
  • From ANON - Isisisatis on January 26, 2004
    Great story idea! Like it very much. So keep the chapters coming, ehem, please :-)! I won't join in the voices crying poor Erestor until it is clear if he was raped or if he only pretended. Anyway I'm somebody who would say to him 'deal with it' *eg*. But of course I would like everything to turn out just happy.

    Isis
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on January 26, 2004
    Poor Erestor!Elrond's such a jerk!If he was a true friend to Erestor,why would it bother him as to the sire of the child?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on January 26, 2004
    Oh, my!!! This is really good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Keep on writing and update soon, please. I can't wait for Glorfindel to appears, I hope he would be nice with poor Erestor...
    Report Review

  • From ANON - louise_oblique on January 26, 2004
    Poor poor erestor, I admit I think he's not lying he seems very believable, please continue. I'm also wondering about Erestor's age as well now, just how old is he? (be ironic if Elrond's advisior is a youth or reletivly young and no one realised) so unfair he's the subject of gossip and seen as heartless whlist he's dying inside and shy because of all his suffering. I admit I am hoping that Erestor was raped as it is unbeliveblely wrong to lie about such a thing and from you dipiction I don't think Erestor is like t Als Also don't like Thrandil in this, get the feeling he was using Elrond and Elrond never realised, be interesting to see how the twins do in Mirkwood. Then we have whatever reaction Thrandil will have when he finds out, meep difficult one. Also wondering about Glofindel. love your characterisations anyway, esspecially Erestor and Elrond. Poor poor Erestor plus Elronds anger understandable if he so love's Thrandil I guess but he was so so so mean to Erestor *cries, painful*. About Lorine, if the Lady of the Goldenwoods can read minds surly she can detect deciete and will realise Erestor's innocence I hope. Also though it may seem i a i always wonder about Erestor's early life and parents and so on, linking in with the age thing got me curious. anyway please please update soon, need someone to believe and support erestor *hopes* and also want elrod to feel guilty :)

    huggs
    louise
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ElizaAnne on January 25, 2004
    I like this story! Keep it coming! Poor Erestor....
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Arnettra on January 25, 2004
    Wow! What a story! Your Erestor is completely believeable and so is your Elrond, his reaction to Erestor's confession rings of truth. I hope you continue to develop this story, it is intriguing.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on January 25, 2004
    Moreover,Elrond would not really banish Erestor and his child would he?I mean,what would be the benefit to Erestor if he was lying?At least now Erestor knows that Elrond will not love him as a lover should.Poor Erestor!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on January 24, 2004
    So,did something happen between Erestor/Thranduil?Is he the sire?PooR Erestor!Would love to read more.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!