Click Here!

Reviews for Greenleaf & Imladris 22-Bereth:To Have and To Hold

By : MPB
  • From ANON - Mel on February 24, 2004
    Legolas is keeping secrets??? Hmmmm.. I have a guess as to what the secret could be. I won't say here though, because I'd really hate to spoil your story for all your fans. It still doesn't explain his attitude toward my favorite elf, though.
    I'm glad Elladan is there this time to knock some sense into Legs if need be. Not to mention Thrandy turning him over his knee!!
    This is such a great story - I'm so glad you're sharing it with us. Thanks!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Somali on February 24, 2004
    In my opinion, Legolas is far off from making enough amends to Elrohir. I seriously have no idea as to wh's 's behaving like this. It's heartbreaking to see Elrohir's moods swinging from extremes from Legolas's actions. *sigh*
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Rainien on February 24, 2004
    A-HA! Clues! And a Plan! And a male Elf who is not so much an idiot at this point in time!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tinni on February 24, 2004
    Thanks for all the personal reassurances. At least I can take heart that everything will work out. But that doesn't make me want to bash Legolas's head it any less. Honestly I keep tearing my hair out over this "evil". Is the doing of the bat-woman, what's her name, I can't remember. You know the vampire that morgoth had in his service. She's dead but maybe someone like her.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tux on February 23, 2004
    Hmmm, an uncommunicative, cranky husband - I SO know how Elrohir feels! lol

    How many chapters are you going to torture us with this time Eresse?!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - spiffy on February 23, 2004
    ???????????????????
    I haven't the foggiest notion where you're going with this piece - and - I love it!
    Wonderful, skillful, imaginative writing as Always. You are soooooo talented its disgusting.
    I look forward to your next installment with puzzlement and bated breath . . .
    spiffy

    Report Review

  • From ANON - louise_oblique on February 23, 2004
    *Cries* that is so sad, just what is up with him? very good, another excwllent fic

    huggs
    louise
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on February 23, 2004
    I really hope that Legolas stays true to his binding with Elrohir.That he id it out of love for him and not out of friendship.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Dark Angel on February 23, 2004
    I can't decide who I am more upset with, Legolas for acting that way or Elrohir doindoing nothing about it. I really, realy hope he does something about it because I fell very bad for him :(

    And as some of those who commented, this is also my absolutley favorite story!

    P.S. Changed nick, now I'm Dark Angel, used to be Gilraen :P
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Shiera on February 23, 2004
    This keeps getting better and better!

    Every chapter has me bitting my nails, or has my eyes wide open in shock and expectancy! You never let the reader down!
    This is the best LOTR fanfic I have ever read!
    This is amazing writing and story-telling! Please continue!

    Eagerly awaiting more!

    ~Shiera
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kirameki on February 23, 2004
    *jaw drops to floofloor* |O_O| Oh. My. God. I can not believe Legolas! How could he say those things! I want to hit him more than I did BEFORE they got together! I had difficulty reading it and was hard pressed to continue. , po, poor Elrohir. What HAS happened to his loving archer? It almost makes me wanna cry. I hope Legolas comes to terms with himself or whatever is causing him to act thusly soon or else I can't guarantee his safety. |-_-;|
    Report Review

  • From ANON - lego forever on February 23, 2004
    I meant ... I remain loyal to him ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - lego forever on February 23, 2004
    Eresshankhanks for responding to the reviews. I noticed that you have been constrained to respond to the reviews of this story twice already - unlike the last tiAs fAs far as i'm concerned, my being "disturbed" is a good thing because it holds my interest. There are stories which I have tried to read and follow but I found disturbing in a totally different sense that I just stopped and decided that it isn't worh my time with the intenet; but yours is an altogether different story. That's why I believe that you would not take your readers in the same thread as Calenlass. It had a good plot but that one is over and I do give you much much more credit than just to expect a repeat of that plot in this story. It's just maybe your avid readerse soe so affected by the last one that they have not quite emotionally recovered from the emotional turmoil of the last story (which I credit to your superb writing ability) that they were not yet prepared to go through another one so soon. Anyway, don't mind our comments much. I love this story already like the ones before it. I guess Legolas is frightened about losing himself, his own identity with this pull he is feeling. I know he is not a witless wood elf and his good traits are not only centered of his warrior skills. remain loyal to him ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Rainien on February 23, 2004
    LOL Heaven protect us all from males who have no idea what's going on inside their heads or hearts - or if they do, deny it to those ones who should mean the most. Yes, I still think Legolas needs to be smacked. He's reminding me far too much of my ex-husband right now and that's REALLY not working in his favor. *waves her hand in the air to brush away thoughts of idiot males* Once again, well done. Till tomorrow....... *S*
    Report Review

  • From MPB on February 23, 2004
    Dear Norah: There *will* be Legolas angst later. Elrohir isn't going to carry that burden all throughout the story.

    Hi lego forever: No, he isn't stupid or thoughtless. Ignorant of some things and misguided in others would be closer to the mark. Let's just say the upcoming expedition is going to prove catalytic in many ways.

    This is already the second time I've replied publicly and it's only Chapter 3. But I just want to put you all at ease if I can. I'm truly sorry if this story has proven disturbing to some of you and hope you'll continue to bear with me *and* my two protagonists until their problem is solved. Thank you for all your wonderful support and helpful comments.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!