Click Here!

Reviews for The Forgotten Ring

By : Sienna
  • From ANON - ned on October 09, 2005
    Just finished reading this great story. Bit of a worry that Haldir had to wait over 1000 years before he finally got his leg over, but apart from that, very good.

    One question though, is there a Chapter missing between 36 and 38. One minute Haldir and elves watching Eridani killing orcs and driving them back towards the elves on the ground, with chapter ending with Haldir just about to face a large orc, the next chapter has Haldir and Eridani descending into the caves under the Palace apparently through a door in Ronihim's charmbers. Point is when did Haldir and Eridani meet up again and how did they find the door and realise the traitor was Ronihim. Sorry, I may be a bit slow, but did I miss something that everyone else got?????
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MarzBar on March 15, 2005
    Thank you so much for this fabulous adventure and romance. I am always happy when the beautiful Haldir finds a true love (even if it's not me).
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cassandra on December 29, 2004
    I just read this straight through and loved it. I am reading the Pentanath and For the Love of Maia and I am completely entranced. I love your writings. You have secured a fan!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sorynliv on December 23, 2004
    Fantastic story. Very creative, well written and well researched. Thank you for the pleasure of reading such a wonderful piece.
    PS....it's nice to see some LOTR het....not to mention Haldir...yum ;-)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Talasi on November 20, 2004
    Sienna,
    This is absolutely wonderful! I can't believe I missed this story before. I have not yet caught up. I'ma bout halfway through, but I sincerely hope you update regularly. Stunning imagery!!!!

    Talasi
    Report Review

  • From ANON - marcianightengale on November 18, 2004
    Sienna, I've checked back every day to see if you'd updated/finished this and your other wonderful stories. This one in particular, I love, but, no! I love them all!! Thank you so very much for sharing your wonderful imagination. Looking forward to more Pentanath and For Love of a Maia and sorry you're work schedule has been so rough. You're a real trouper to have continued to write in the face of such adversity. I hope it gives you as much pleasure to write your stories as it gives your readers to read them. I've recommended them widely. Marcia
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on November 17, 2004
    A fabulous story, Sienna. I've very much enjoyed reading about the trials and tribulations of Haldir and Eridani, and am very happy that, in the end, all turned out well. What a perfect ending for such a beautiful story. Thank you for sharing your story with us. I'll be looking forward to reading your updates for your other stories...keep up the good work, and thank you once again for doing such a fantastic job.

    Michelle...
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on October 24, 2004
    Wow, Eridani and Haldir have finally gotten it right! YAY!!! I loved the chapter...it was hot, sexy, AND romantic. Loved it!

    I cant wait to read more, so, update soon! :D

    Mich...
    ...

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on October 17, 2004
    What a great title for your latest chapter! Indeed, what would you say to someone after all that time. Obviously, regardless of the time that has gone by, these two are still unable/or unwilling to tell each other how they really . Th. Things never seem to go smoothly for these two. *sighs*

    Apparently, my other reviews didn't post, so hopefully this one will go through! Keep posting and keep up the good work :D


    Report Review

  • From ANON - Allana on September 25, 2004
    Beautiful. I can't wait for your next update.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on September 19, 2004
    I'm so happy that the Valar spared Eridani. She and Haldir certainly deserve to have a life together, after all that they've sacrificed. I'm not surprised that Eridani would believe that Haldir was no longer in love with her, though...Tamarcil's demeanor did suggest that he was withholding information. Ohhhhh, I can't wait for the reunion!

    ***sighs*** I love this story...please update soon. : D

    Michelle...
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Ellen on September 18, 2004
    Wow. This has been the most incredible journey and I hope there's more to come. Beautifully written.

    Thank you.

    Ellen
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on September 06, 2004
    And so, the journey begins for Eridani and Haldir. I can't wait to find out what adventures they will experience! Saruman is involved so I know that there will be much evil and treachery for them to overcome. I look forward to reading exactly how they plan on overcoming the huge obstacles, that I'm sure that they will have to face. Great chapter...

    Update soon... : )
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on August 27, 2004
    Interesting developments in this chapter. The Moon Beast's revelations about Eridani's role in the future was shocking. Who would have guessed that she would play such an important role, in the future? But now, I wonder, should she tell Haldir or not?
    I don't know...

    And why did Eridani put the ring on? She must have been COMPLETELY lost in thought if she was so careless as to do that.

    I can't wait to find out what Eridani's plans are...and how she goes about carrying them out. Great chapter, update soon...

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Michelle on July 31, 2004
    Hi! I absolutely love your writing style.

    Is her nephew going to kill or kidnap her? He obviously knows that she's hiding something. This is an outstanding story, and I can't wait for you to update. Wha goi going to happen????? Grrr, must know NOW!!!!!
    ***crosses fingers and hopes for an update***
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!