Click Here!

Reviews for Twilight Tales - Hallowed Fate

By : MPB
  • From ANON - Lada on June 29, 2004
    I think the best way for Imrahil to choose immortality and sail with Elladan to Valinor. Because if he will not, someday Imrahil will die in Arda even with children, grandchildren and great grand children around him (they love him so much but just as family does). And may be Imrahil will live another 80 years but it would be for him like to become a widow for the second time in his life. Elladan will be alive but so far from him and they will never be together and both of them will grive. But if Imrahil will choose to go with Elladan, even he will leave his family which will happen anyway he still will enjoy his love and spouse close to him. This is my silly opinion and I hope that Imrahil will sail with his spouse Elladan and will have an eternity of happyness and love!:-)
    Thank you, Eresse. And I have a request (if I may:-), don't, please, end the story so suddenly with their departure, please, write a chapter about Imrahil's arrival to Valinor and his impression and may be a little about their life together there (If of couse you will make Imrahil to choose immortality which I hope with all my heart).
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MJLuvsPolar on June 26, 2004
    Another wonderful update Eresse! I can cheerfully say that I'm over my little Elladan hissy fit. It tickles me to think of Imrahil behaving like a teenager with a secret love, though I must say I really am looking forward to the 'secret' being out, if only for the ruckass that is sure to ensue. I'd really like to say more but I'm deathly afraid of notng ang able to post this message - it took me a few hours just to *read* the update this morning. :-(

    As always, I'm looking forward to reading the next chapter.

    Marie
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on June 26, 2004
    I love your previous stories including this one.Whatever the reason for Elladan's coming to Dol Amroth,it sounds bad.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lada on June 26, 2004
    It's incrediblly good and lovely chapter! But I so hope that Elladan didn't come to tell that he is goint to depart to Valinor! It would not make sence, because Aragorn is still ting ing and alive. Legolas will not leave untill his death, as long as Legolas is in Arda Elrohir will stay with him. Thus, Elladan will be there as well though he will never live Imrahil while they can enjoy their marrige. I can't think what is it, the news Elladan brought? Now I am wondering how old is Imrah-) S-) Silly me can't count correctly:-) And he didn't change in his apperance at all. I am just thinking if their marrage was blessed by Valar, may be they will let Elladan bring Imrahil with him, even Imrahil is a human, and humans are forbiden to come to Undying Land, but still Imrahil has elven blood as well. I just think that may be Imrahil has to let his eldest sone to become a ruler of Dol Amroth and just "retired" for he will be ready and free to go with Elladan anywhere to Imladris or wherever they have to go just simply to be together. I suggest that his sons are old enouth to rule the country without their father's advices and support.
    Anyway, thank you, Eresse, and please, continue this story as long as possible:-))
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on June 26, 2004
    What bad news does Elladan have??? Their tale is wonderful Eresse! I so hope that I am not left in tears at the end...
    This chapter answered my question about Imrahil's family knowing of his bonding.
    You write such moving love stories...
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sian on June 23, 2004
    Great update Eresse!
    Just wondering how Imrahil family reacted to his espousal, or do they know?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Minuial Nuwing on June 23, 2004
    Thank the Valar! I nearly went into 'Hallowed Fate' withdrawal while AFF.net was down! I am very glad to find Imrahil safe at home...and I loved the flashback to the earlier visit (grin)...but what a cruel place to stop! Wonderful chapter, incredible writing, as always...

    Minuial ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - rozzan on June 23, 2004
    Oh wonderful, binding fulfillment at last! And Elladan submitting, always a turn on.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lada on June 19, 2004
    Well, They did bind to each other!:-) Hah, I knew it, it was very logical after their sweet and emotional reunion:-) Thank you, Eresse again for a wonderfully continuing story! I hope they will be together as often as possible. Iil dil deserved to be loved and I am happy that Elladan really loves him. I am looking forward to read more of the story, please, continue soon!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kitty on June 19, 2004
    Another great chapter! I'm glad Elladan and Imrahil have bonded! But I am a bit worried about Elladan - do this mean he has to remain in Middle-earth forever? This would be so very sad! Maybe Imrahil can join him in Valinor because of his own elvish blood and as a reward for Elladan? Such an ending would be so much happier!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sian on June 19, 2004
    How wonderful that was, so happy they worked out their differences. I still am wondering if we will have an happy ending, I know you said its AU, so I hope that means yes, but he is mortal.....
    Report Review

  • From nuwing on June 19, 2004
    Amazing...it seems with every chapter that this story can surely not improve, but it continues to get better and better! The description of Imrahil's reaction to the binding was wonderful, as always, and your Elladan remains beyondds. ds.

    I am sure you already have the ending of this marvelous tale decided...and I sincerely hope your 'undocumented' conclusion entails Imrahil joining Elladan in Valinor. If not, I could easily be persuaded to grovel and beg, if it would help... **pitiful sigh and puppy-dog eyes***

    Minuial ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lada on June 14, 2004
    Wondeful chapter, Eresse! And I got the answer on my question:-) Thank you so much for creating very sensitive scene between lladan and Imrahil. It seems they are very ready to create the bond between them as before. Imrahil feels Elladan thoughts. That was very emotional I was crying again (happy tears):-)
    And I misspell last time one name:-) I just hope Erestor will forgive me!:-) I like Er/Gl pairing very much!
    Please, update soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Minuial Nuwing on June 14, 2004
    I am once again forced to repeat myself, which is not a bad thing! Wonderfully composed, beautifully written...absolutely lovely. Hat off, head bowed...

    Minuial ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MGC on June 14, 2004
    Finally!

    I vote for the Glory/Erestor story first. I'm dying to read the Lego/Ro prequel to this.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!