Click Here!

Reviews for Twilight Tales - Hallowed Fate

By : MPB
  • From ANON - eawen penallion on June 13, 2004
    I love your writings, they are amongst the best on the net! The Greenleaf and Imladris series was superb. I haven't finished reading this tale but am enjoying every minute. Personally I am an Erestor/Glorfindel fan, I loved their story in G & I so I would love to see that story next

    Keep writing, I'll certainly keep reading

    eawen penallion
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lieta on June 13, 2004
    Thank you for the story! I eagerly await the next part, and really, really hope Elladan won't have to suffer for an eternity. There must be a way!

    As for the three tales, I would like to read the one with Glorfindel and Erestor in it first. The one about them was one of my favourites in the Greenleaf and Imladris series (although I absolutely loved every one of them, especiallt the more angsty ones).
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kitty on June 13, 2004
    That's much better - I've known it, Elladan wouldn't only play with Imrahil, it had to be true love! Good old Elrohir, he has helped so much!
    Well, this is quite a mess. Poor Imrahil, poor Elladan! It wil not be easy for them - I can't think of a way for them to solve this problem without much grief especially for Elladan. But I trust you, Eresse - surely you will come up with something of a surprise for us! I think you've once told us you love happy endings, too - so I will wait for it ;-)

    As for the next story: although I love all your writing and will read all three stories eagerly I think I would prefer Glorfindel/Erestor first, because I'm really curious how this will continue - maybe it is about their babe?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - groovy on June 13, 2004
    Hello, greetings from Colombia!!

    OH! please make it glorfindel and Erestor first!! I want to know wath happens to them!...and then you can post Elrond Legy!!...and so on... any pair you write about, I know will end in a beutyful story...just look wath you did with Elladan and Imrahil... by the way...please make their love came true!! they love each other so much!!...*sigh*
    bye...claudia.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - lego forever on June 12, 2004
    Well as usual, another excellent chapter and explanation. Though I expect more would be coming once the two lovers talk. I have an idea but I want to really know why Elladan reacted the way he did when Imrahil playfully struggled with him on the bed. As for the coming stories, you know where my affections lie... I want Legolas and Elrohir stories but I guess I want all three right away so that I could read the prequel of this story. How greedy and shameful of me!!!! Thanks for your continually writitng and sharing stories with us!!!!!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From MJLuvsPolar on June 12, 2004
    Eresse, I feel like I've just been through the spin cycle of my washing machine - my emotions are all over the shop! I'm still annoyed with Elladan (though I guess not as much as I was yesterday ) because he was just going to let Imrahil go. Stupid Elf! Isn't he lucky that he has Elrohir looking out for him? You described Elladan's painting so well that I find myself wanting to see it for myself. Oh and I loved the little tidbit about Elrohir worrying about keeping Legolas away from Elladan until things blow over - Legolas with a temper just tickles me, who knows why! Again Imrahil is being the better 'man' about things, he really is a very lovable person. I just hope that Elladan doesn't try and push him away again because even forgiving people have a limit and it obvious that Imrahil has been very hurt.

    Ok well enough philosophizing for one Sunday morning. As for your question about what to post next, I vote for the Legolas/Elrond story for all the reasons I've previously bored you with!

    Cheers
    Marie :-)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - tfutcher on June 12, 2004
    i love ow this is going. you ave me angry at elladan at one moment and then feeling sorry for him later. I want to see all the stories but especially the glorfindel/erestor story I want to see how they get on
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lada on June 12, 2004
    It was wonderful! I was crying for Imrahil in chapter 10. God, I could not believe that Eladan easily without even thinking has broken the heart of the noble and highly respectful man. And even after explainations in chapter 11 I am still puzzled of the purpose of Elladan to aproach Imrahil at the very first time. Why is he so obbssesed with Dol Amroth princelings? Very strange! And I agree, there will be no happy ending in this story, I could not see the opportunity for them to be happy together though I love happy ends, but I believe my heart will be broken at the end:-( If they will decide to be apart as Imrahil knows now that Elladan could not stay with him till the very death, their hearts will be still broken! I hope Eresse somehow will resolve this.
    For the new story I would like to read about Glorfindel and Ereston, but up to the author, because all stories of Eresse are wonderfud bed beautifully written! I like them very much indeed.
    Can't wait for continuing!:-)
    Report Review

  • From trekqueen on June 12, 2004
    hopefully this review of mine will not be lost like my first one by aff! *grumbles* stupid sql errors...
    anyways, awwwwwwwwww I felt so bad for Imrahil before, now I feel just as bad for Elladan! I want them to get together but I fear for their love to meet grief! Though, I know you will come up with something good!

    oh btw, I would loooooooove to see the glory erestor fic first!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sian on June 12, 2004
    Ah, now I understand, and I can not see a happy ending... As for what you post next, anyone of the mentioned stories will be eagerly read! I would like to see the different Legolas ad Elrohir story, but I also love the other ngs ngs as well.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Minuial Nuwing on June 12, 2004
    Bless you for posting this...I was having a terrible time being angry with Elladan! (VBG) Lovely, as always, and I am waiting with a pitiful lack of patience for the next installment! :)
    My vote goes to Glorfindel/Erestor, but I'm easy- I'll read and undoubtedly enjoy whichever you do first!

    Min ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sarah on June 12, 2004
    I need your storys like I need the sun! All your storys are really wonderful. Legolas and Elrohir is the couple that I really love. so I would prefer to read more about them in the following story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nia on June 12, 2004
    Ah, you shouldn't torture us so! I absolutely love chapters like this, but I must know what comes next!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - anna on June 12, 2004
    Dear eresse,

    What a chapter! I literally cried! I feel so sad for our poor Imrahil. I really love Elladan, but this time I would like to shout on him. can can he be so stupid not to think about what can happen when someone is playing with the feelings of others?Please, I neeeeeed the next chapter!!!!

    Thank you for your wonderful storys (I miss Greenwood and Imladris very, very much).
    Report Review

  • From ANON - rozzan on June 12, 2004
    Eresse, (CH.10) I really want to leave you a considered intelligent review, which shows you how much I admire your story but I can't.

    I can barely see the keyboard! The tears are literally pouring down my face as I feel Imrahil's acute pain and Elladan's shame.
    You have reduced me to a sobbing mess. However are you going to get them out of this mess? I can only trust to your wonderful creativity that you will.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!