Click Here!

Reviews for Ring Around the Merry

By : emma
  • From ANON - Julie on June 30, 2003
    This story is going on forever, and nothing is happening! Is there any point to it at all besides torturing Pippin and Frodo? Every single chapter is just like the one before. If you're not going to make something happen, please just end it. It gets old seeing the same things happen to the same characters over and over again. This could be a good idea if you would put in some levels. Maybe if sometimes Merry realized how bad he was being and tried to stop it?

    Just please, make something new happen soon or else write the end, It's really, really boring now.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - The Morrigan on June 29, 2003
    I found this story recently while surfing this site-I was immediately sucked in. It's a very interesting AU to explore-somehow, having Merry as the baddie is very believable! I'm looking forward to more. This is, overall, a well-written story, with cliffhangers galore. I do have one wee criticism, though-I'm a lifelong Pippin fan, and I'm feeling very bad for the poor guy! I'm just hoping he sees the light soon!

    The Morrigan
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on June 29, 2003
    Worst story ever! Oh my gosh, you must hate these characters something fierce. NO explanation or reason for evil!Merry other than, "oh, guess what my little pea brain is going to do. hehehehe." Oops, I forgot. This can't be the worst story ever since Nasty Hobbits is. OTOH, since this one was inspired by that, I dunno. It's a close call for worst LOTR fanfic ever.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - quendria on June 22, 2003
    Your RAtM is exquisite! I love your writing style, you keep me hanging on your every word. Please don't ever stop! I am female...Why do we enjoy slash so much?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Heather on June 22, 2003
    I'm a girl, sorry 'bout that. My dad does think I;m something of a tomboy though, and I'm inclined to agree with him. I'm not as interested as joining the army though, as he wants me too be. :)

    Another great chapter, so continue quickly, okay?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kyotyred on June 22, 2003
    Enthralling as usual. I am so happy you updated so quickly. I even took a break from reading the new Harry Potter to read this upate. A wonderful jobn'tn't wait for more.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Heather on June 20, 2003
    I don't know weather to laugh, or to cry. Good chapter, so please continue quick.

    Can't wait.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aleana on June 12, 2003
    So, so, so very good.

    Please, continue soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maikafuiniel on June 10, 2003
    Woa. Freaky, but very, very good.

    Please, continue soon, or I'll go crazy.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aratlithiel on May 26, 2003
    Ch. 18

    Why is no one else reviewing this fabulous fic.?! I can tell you're out there, following along and enjoying so send lovely Emma a note & tell her!!

    This is one of my favorite chapters and very aptly named. You've written Sam so well - a combination of kindheartedness and plain old pissed off hobbit. And whacking Merry was almost as satisfying for me as it must have beer hir him. Very nicely done.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aratlithiel on May 05, 2003
    (chap. 14) OK - I don't feel sorry for Merry anymore. I think this ter ter was extremely well done. The psychology behind Merry's chosen punishment of Pip is fascinating and a great set-up for future conflict and angst. Keep posting!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aratlithiel on April 27, 2003
    “You are LEASHING me, Merry?” asked Frodo, half-annoyed, half-aghast.

    I don't know why this is my favorite line, but it is. And gosh, but Ialmoalmost (almost, mind you) feeling bad for Merry here. He's so sure that he's protecting Frodo but OH! I'm very worried about what else he'll do in the name of protection. OK, not worried - looking forward to more like, but hey, we all have our little eccentricities. Your story just happens to be mine.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Taioarmi on April 27, 2003
    Sam is certainly a most brilliant hobbit isn't he? Yeah, I need a friend like Sam. Everyone needs a Sam. *nods* Merry has lost his poor little mind, Pippin is so in love he's almost oblivious to what goes on around him, and Frodo...poor Frodo. *sighs* I love this though and demand you update soon, becuase I reviewed. ^-^ Feed me!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Elfishgal on April 27, 2003

    well it is certainly ... diffrent, but very well written, and I liked it so far!
    BTW , thanks a lot for the review you left on my story, I live for reviews!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aratlithiel on April 26, 2003
    Echoes here of the Frodo/Faramir debate - excellent use of language. It's so very hard to dislike Merry, although I have faith you'll give us plenty of reasons to do so later. Bwa ha ha ha!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!