Click Here!

Reviews for Lonely Hearts

By : ihgs123
  • From ANON - Twilight on December 25, 2003
    Thanks for the chapter on Christmas Day! Even though Glorfindel is not in love with Erestor right now, Glorfindel is willing to be open to it and allow thnd tnd to bring them closer. Previously, I thought Glorfindel may have some hidden feelings for Erestor when he was so upset about Erestor having cheated with his lover. Apparently, it does not seem that way.

    Surprised so many people knew about Elrond's infatuation millenia ago with Arthon, but Arthon never knew. Doesn't Arthon have any friends back then who would have teased him about the young Elrond? Liked the added part with Stinah and Semar a lot. Stinah is such a good caring friend to Semar and can help him in his relationship with Huor.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Devious on December 25, 2003
    I am glad that Erestor and Glorfindel are getting along.I cannot wait for Haldir and Stinah in the next chapter.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 23, 2003
    Though the lie about Semar's relationship with Stinah will certainly cause trouble later, it seems Huor would not have realized or admitted to himself how he felt deep down about Semar, without the possibility of having lost Semar. Good angsty scenes.

    I'm curious what Elladan is thinking and feeling about Elrohir and himself, now that he appears to be so mischievious in his pinching of Elrohir's butt. Thanks for the upcoming Christmas gift of chapter 30. Merry Christmas!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on December 23, 2003
    Poor Huor getting jealous without knowing his true feelings towards Semar.As for Stinah,since he still loves Haldir,thye should just kiss and make up or maybe more.MHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Laurel on December 23, 2003
    Err... isn't it kind of in poor taste on Arthon's behalf to have his ex-wife at the wedding. O_o;;
    Report Review

  • From ANON - mirasaui on December 21, 2003
    I just love this story! So many Elves in love with another but refraining to tell them so through foolish notions or fear. Can't wait to see them all work out!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Devious on December 21, 2003
    Oh my God,I cannot beleive it that Elrond didn't recognize Arthon behind that mask.And I can't wait for Huor and Semar in the next one.LOL
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 21, 2003
    Nice flashback with Arthon. Both in love with each other but never able to recognize or tell the other.

    What an interesting ploy by Stinah and Semar to fake a relationship to cause Haldir and Huor to feel jealous. It will be fun to see the promiscuous Huor jealous and finally in love with someone. Also, it will be fun to see Haldir jealous. He appears to have realized his mistake, has mended his ways, and wants Stinah back.

    Don't know if Haldir or Huor might become angry later upon finding out about the ploy. Love your story, please update soon!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 14, 2003
    I do feel more sympathy for Arthon for his past, though other elves with unrequited loves have not turned out so bitter, cold and hostile as he has. Since Elrond had a crush on him, he could not recognize those signs from Elrond, especially being so much older?

    I surprised anyone would want to marry him, unless it was a political marriage. Thanks for the short chapter. Hoping for more when you are can.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Devious on December 07, 2003
    Oh,Erestor's and Glorfindel's playful attitude is so cute,but what of Haldir and Stinah.There will get back together,won't they.And what about Arthon's past.Why is he hating Elrond so much.Please more!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on December 06, 2003
    I feel sorry for Semar because he might suffer a heartbreak if Huor is really only playing with his feelings.But I hope that there will be more of Haldir and Stinah.Will they ever reconcile?You're doing a great job kiki!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 06, 2003
    Yay, another chapter! Keep feeding those sweets to your muse. tortor's and Glorfindel's discussion about Arthon's breakfast visit was funny. Having to be nice to unpleasant relatives comes with being bonded. Nice playful banter between the two.

    Nice scene with Semar and Huor. Wondering if Huor was as affected by that kiss as Semar was. Even with his vast experience, hope so.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - HHS on December 05, 2003
    So what's stopping Arthon from telling Elrond on what happened int he past?His pride?To hell with it!I just hope that don't kill each other.As for Haldir and Stinah,they still do love each other.Ai,both of them are stubborn!!!More!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 05, 2003
    What an interesting twist that Arthon loved Elrond all those many ages ago. Guess he was so mean to Elrond out of frustration and jealousy all of those years ago? With Gil-galaad out of the picture, why is Arthon still so angry and nasty to Elrond? Did Elrond become Gil-galaad's lover even though he had a crush or feelings for Arthon?

    With Stinah staying in his room (if he stays that is), Haldir will need to make the most of his opportunity to gain Stinah's trust and love back.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Twilight on December 02, 2003
    Another chapter, yay! A very happy reader here. Yay, Elladan and Elrohir are back. How fortunate Haldir and Elrohir was there to get Arthon off of Elrond. Looking forward to Stinah and Haldir meeting up in your next chapter.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!