Click Here!

  • 1

Reviews for What Gain Was Theirs

By : LonelyWhisper
  • From JazzieXGackt on July 10, 2008
    OoO

    OMG&G that was amazing XS!
    The first one was so...calm and nervous and I was like stuck in the emotions of both;
    and the second one was just the same! I was struggling to breath with Haldir and Eomer...I felt the heaviness of the evil and suddenly peace...it was odd...o..O
    I don't think a ff has ever moved me like this....I *HAVE* to see if you have any more stories...or atleast harrass you until you decided to continue writing this one XD you figure out which one XD!!

    thank you for writing this XD TOTALY MADE MY NIGHT! ::faithful fan now::
    Report Review

  • From JazzieXGackt on July 10, 2008
    awwwww! ::sobs::that's so sweet! ::dabs eyes with tissue:: i'm good ::sniffs:: i'm good ::cries:: D; that was amazing.....::huggles little plushies of the two close::
    Report Review

  • From KittyMeowMaxwell on January 06, 2008
    Wow. Just wow. I dislike "wow" reviews, because they are not helpful to the writer, but when something is so profound, it's a little difficult to say anything but! It would have made a good one-shot, indeed, the ending would have been good. Poignant. But I'm glad you chose to continue. I like how you've switched back and forth from the present to the past and so on. The disjointed feeling seems to fit with how both Eomer and Haldir are feeling at the moment - it reads very well. I feel for them both. I hope you continue, and will definitely read when you do!

    ~KittyMeowMaxwell
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Pointless . Romantic on August 18, 2007
    Genius!
    Genius, I say!
    I wish I had thought of this couple!
    It's just crack enough to work!
    >w
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Teri on January 28, 2007
    This was totally outstanding. Please, please, please, you must finish this fic. It is too good to let go of.
    Take Care,
    Teri

    Report Review

  • From trekqueen on February 04, 2006
    oooh you're giving me shivers! I'm liking this very much so far. Usually I'm not one for slash but I came across a good writer last year that let me believe there are good slash writers out there and I have found another! I can't wait to see what will come of Haldir and Eomer. Haldir Lives!!! :D
    Report Review

  • From ANON - WorshipAllElves on February 03, 2006
    Great job! I love your story. Please don't wait so long to update again!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anita on February 03, 2006
    It was an awesome chapter! I relly liked how you handled their feelings an their emotions! you managed to do a really sweet and caring bond between the two of them!!! AWESOME!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anita on February 01, 2006
    It is a nice piece of work! I really enjoyed it!! you are an awesome writer!
    Report Review

  • From Remetan on February 01, 2006
    Egads, but this is a beautiful story, Corvis! Good Lord! The imagery is fantastic, the struggle of these two strong men to maintain their power and honour, the dialogue you have written. Very powerful. The only thing I would recommend is looking at the places where you have capitalized the word man. I get that you did it for a reason, but the reason is unclear to me in its current formation. However, just could not stop reading!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Larisse on January 11, 2006
    I like your story very much. Lovely writing. So glad that Haldir still lived, and loved Eomer's loyalty. Would love to see a sequel.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sesshybebe9 on December 26, 2005
    Very entertaining piece! I can see why you had to put the idea down, it would've been the same for me! I've never read one with Eomer and Haldir's character's so well placed in a more dramatic plotline other than yours, and because there aren't many, and aren't many that are GOOD- I encourage you to continue this ABSOLUTLEY! It's good, and exciting and the cliffhanger at the end of that first chapter is killing me!
    Kick ASS!
    ~Kira
    Report Review

  • 1
T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!