Click Here!

Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name

By : Celesta
  • From ANON - Cait on March 21, 2004
    *so happy*
    You made my week. I havent been online for a few days but reading your newly updated chapter made up for it. Can't wait for the following chapter. Again, a marvelous fic. I shall definetly check out your other fics soon. Later
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yue on March 20, 2004
    this is a great chapter. i love it. you proportioned their love perfectly. i thought i was goin to cry!! ahaahaha. i was hoping for more than a lemon but this is great none the less. i hope u get the chance to write a new chapter and update soon. till next time.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Guthwyn on March 19, 2004
    Hi! I read a couple of sections of your story and although you aren't bad, there are some things...

    Just wanted to let you know that you shouldn't write for the fans- you should write for yourself. Yeah, sure, it's great to know people really enjoy your work, but honestly, why should one have to write for other people? I personally don't give a damn how many people think something's wrong with my story- in fact, I'm so sick of my friends automatically telling me it's good (because they don't want to hurt my feelings) that I *wantmeonmeone to tell me what's wrong with it.

    So maybe you should listen to the "flames" (which sound more like severe, yet constructive criticism to me). I'm not saying you have to like them, but some of them might have some helpful information.

    And again, you really should write for yourself. It's a lot easier that way.

    Navaer!

    P.S. 'Anon' is also short for 'anonymous', so the anon who liked and the anon who "flamed" are probably two different people.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sister kitty on March 19, 2004
    Ah Celesta???

    Can i have my screen back now?

    I would like to read the new chapter?


    Please??????


    Great story - are we going to see some lemons in the bath????
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 19, 2004
    i would just like to inform you that your story was so good that i have spent the last two hours readit ait and now my eyes are burning from looking at the screen this long and it is now five in the morning and and instead of getting ready to go to work i am giving up my precious hair blo-drying time to write this review for you! it was just that damn good! i applaud you! i love it all and i very eagerly await your next chapter. (this is gonna sound corny but im going to say it anyways) you have truly brightened my life by just writing this fic. i love middle earth with all my heart and i wish i was an elf not for the immortality or the beauty (those are just bonuses) but for the connection with nature. you have shown me that even a human can have that kind of connection. also its nice to read about how much those two love each other. it givves me hope. thank you so very very much. i love you! *wipes tear away* your forver faithful reader-maria
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 19, 2004
    how/where did you learn to speak elvish? i love languages and would love to learn it but its hard to just learn from the books because there isn't enough of it. etc etc etc
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 19, 2004
    i so know what you mean about the whole snuggling thing. its really hard for people to understand that you're not really flirting its just that you need constant contact with someone. i am truly sorry fort hat happened to you and your friends i hope that you all recover and are able to overcome it all. *big hug* i wish i had enough confidence to snuggle nude with people...mmm i need to work out more lol *applauds* < for another great chapter that i absolutly adored. i liked that statement about gandalf shouting to the mountain that it had won and they were leaving . it made me laugh and i got a strange look from my cat.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 19, 2004
    btw...forgot to put this in my last review...could you email me telling me how to pronounce her full name. it'll bug me to no extent. thank you!!!! i love her humor btw...and she is a bit forward which i don't think you should curb one bit but the men might think she is arrogant etc (which i just realized that you show that type of thinking in boromir so ima gonna be quiet now)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 19, 2004
    omg i love this story so far! (even though im only on the first chapter but thats not the point now is it? no its not) i love the way she acted! highly improbable but it was so funny it didn't matter. she was just so nonchalant about it. it was great. and she got to cuddle with leggy!!! if that happened to me...i think id die of sheer happiness! although she was in shock at the time, and probably had no idea what was going on but yeah. ok i'm going to stop rambling because i really wanna know what happens. btw: MARY SUES ROCK!! as long as they have a good plot. if there is no good plot then they suck and i hate them. but so far yours is awesome!!! it'll prolly get better as i read along...which im going to do now....

    maria
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on March 18, 2004
    EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! At least it was a good chapter.... don't take so long next time!! Or else I'll... I'll, uh... do something reeeeally bad! Yeah, you heard me!

    MORE. Now.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sister kitty on March 17, 2004
    You know those flying keyboards you were ducking at the beginning of this chapter????!!!!!

    The have now turned into flying screens!!!!!!!!

    I am hanging on the edge of a knife - I false step and the fellowship will.......

    hang on wrong quote.


    Just write girl - I want more of this fabulous story!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on March 14, 2004
    Niiiiice, I am glad you had Asca stay. You following the book or the movie? If so you better noth ave her leave Lothlorien until the war is won. And when are you going to tell us if she's pergnant or not? You better tell us before Legolas leaves. And make sure you have Haldir get his head out of his a$$. Update soon! Namaarie.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sister kitty on March 11, 2004
    Yihaaaaaaa

    Yipeee

    Well sort of...

    Read your new chapter - great...

    And now accoasionally the firewall lets me in to the story

    Why it will let me into AdultFanFiction but won't let me into the work website, I don't quite know - BUT I'M NOT ARGUING!!!!!


    Keep on writing!!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NightStrider on March 09, 2004
    i love your writing but must you end it there and in that way???? lokking forward to the next chapter
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yue on March 08, 2004
    its so sweet. i like this fic. write more!!! its so sad that they have to part but its understandable. she aint no zena, worrior princess. lol. i hope everything works out fine in the the end. and here's the ever common comment of "UPDATE SOON!!!"
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!