Click Here!

Reviews for ELANOR'S REVENGE

By : Juliediane
  • From MlleGigi on June 21, 2010
    I enjoyed reading this story a great deal -- perhaps because there are places in which it has the characteristics of a Regency romance (another favorite genre of mine). I very much appreciate the way in which you've carefully and consistently maintained character dialogue throughout in order to keep it reminiscent of Tolkien's style, and I like the fact that you've chosen to portray the Elves as deeply emotional beings instead of the cold and detached ones seemingly depicted in the films. Personally, I think that if you found a way to move this story into a world of your own creation instead of placing it within the Tolkien universe, you could even try submitting it for publication since it is in many respects an appealing and well-crafted story.
    Report Review

  • From dornons on August 17, 2007
    Hi, I have already reviewed on this story but I found another story on the site OF Elves and Men and since we have changed our internet I can no longer leave a review on that site. Any way I just read the story Siren and loved it! CAn't wait for the next stories and really liked how you put Haldir in it. Perhaps they will be together when she grows up? Yes?
    Report Review

  • From dornons on July 09, 2007
    BRAVO!!! wonderful ending. I look forward to reading more from you.
    Report Review

  • From mthorsta on July 09, 2007
    What a wonderful journey this has been. Thank you for sharing this incredible story. I have yet to read another story where so many characters were explored with such depth and emotion. I am saddened to reach the end, but I'm sure I will find myself revisiting this story as time goes on. Again, thank you!
    Report Review

  • From luna26 on July 09, 2007
    God I can't believe it over. *sniffle* This was the story that got me hooked on this site and I'm so glad I've stuck with it. You've never disappointed. Congratulations on a story well done. I look forward to more stories in the future.
    Report Review

  • From Teresalynne on June 02, 2007
    I have followed this story with great pleasure and enjoyment! It was great seeing Lana finally start to understand just what her fears about the loss of her parents had done to her family. If she had talked to them about it they could have helped her....sigh. I have to admit it's a pity that she didn't get that spanking though! (chuckle) I wander if Saranion will do his best to avoid his fate? Honestly though, it will take someone like him to deal with her, even with improvement she'll still be a trip! The wedding was lovely, and it was wonderful that Elanor's parents were able to attend before they sailed. I enjoyed seeing how all of Elanor and Haldir's friends and family supported them! I just hope that Tarwe thinks everything over but she does have a point; she did everything she could to help Lurien and he threw it in her face. It's just sad though that she might hurt herself more in the attempt to protect herself..... Thank you both for writng such a wonderful story, and I look forward to reading the epilogue and discovering what happens to your characters!
    Report Review

  • From elvenjade on February 06, 2007
    Okay I feel behind reading this and had to read starting from chapter 28... it took all night andmost of today lol I was hooked as usual and could not stop reading. I love this story very much and will hate to see it end when the time comes. I look forward to reading more..

    Btw I love thelesson the twins gave Lana LOL ( though secretly I was hoping they would drop her lol)
    Report Review

  • From retrodaisy on January 19, 2007
    Wow. This story remains to be wonderful and captivating. Thank you! I very much look forward for the newest installment and happy new year!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Teresa on December 18, 2006
    This was a pleasant suprise! I enjoyed reading this chapter very much! It looks as though Haldir and Lurien might work out all of their differences eventually. It was also interesting to see that Elanor's parents might not be as bad as they seemed. As for Lana...I can hear her tantrum about Elanor and Haldir now! Thanks for the terrific chapter!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - natasha on December 18, 2006
    i just want to say thanks for this freat gift you two.

    a new chapter to read during my holidays, i'm just a little sad it's soon coming to an end
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sugarplum on December 15, 2006
    I was so glad to see an update! And what an update it was!!!!!!! Please continue and hope that Lana gets hers and real soon, sounds like the twins have a lot in store for her and Elanor and Haldir are just so great together! Maybe a marriage in the end? Hope its updated soon!!!
    Report Review

  • From luna26 on December 15, 2006
    another chapter........so happy. I know this must be a labor of love for you but it really really shows. Great story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - M M on December 14, 2006
    So glad that you updated. Love this story.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sugarplum on October 11, 2006
    Oh, goody an update!!!! Love it and now lana will finally get hers! Hopefully the parents will not brow beat ellie into returning with them and give the bratling a chance to weasel her way out of anything! she needs a good spanking! Maybe one of the twins?! anyway don't keep us waiting for too long!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - natasha on October 11, 2006
    i have long read this story, & finally a new chapter.
    i beg both u julie & your partner to get more chapters out QUICK


    Now Rumil's getting married. it looks like all that live in lorien will be married before elanor & haldir....well except for maybe lurien. i'm still mad at him!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!