Click Here!

Reviews for Cuil Eden

By : Esteliel
  • From JirelCahil on December 18, 2009
    This is a great story and I am enjoying the heck out of it. I have to hope you have written something a little more conventional because I have a friend who enjoys stories written by people who understand the emotions, desires and needs that drive others and she would so enjoy this story if she had the same tastes in reading that I do. I would like very much to share your writing with her. You have truly crafted something that becomes more than just written words. Despite the fact that Tolkien would roll over in his grave at the idea of male on male action, he would have to admit that the art that you use in crafting a tale in great.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - vik on December 13, 2009
    I am glad that you start continuing this story again. I am falling in love with Gil. He is so cute!!

    I'm really want to read the special chapter only for Gil discribe how he feel about his adda and atto together. Must be very cute.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - rick on December 09, 2009
    oh good keep going!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Toxic Hathor on December 03, 2009
    Dearest Esteliel,

    First and foremost, please allow me the honor of getting to my knees before you to show you my respect for your amazing, undeniable talent. Not only did you manage to oh-so-perfectly capture the general "air" and "atmosphere" of the Elves and...well, LOTR in general, but you have also done something more beautiful than that. Your portrayal of Legolas' character in a situation like this.

    Please do not heed anything that that..."Avidreader" told you. First of all, it seems that that person has nothing better to do than to go around, putting writers down. I received a not-too-friendly review on one of my stories on ff(dot)net from someone with the exact same penname. Coincidence? I think not...especially not with the way s/he wrote their review, making it sound like constructive criticism when it is blatant bashing.

    That aside, I hail you for the wonderful way you've paced yourself out on this. Starting with the very first part and up to the 68th chapter, everything seems to be going at a wonderful pace...I usually get so BORED with long fictions, but truly, Anestel is an exception to that habit of mine. You...made it perfect. What more can I say, oh great Esteliel...?

    Keep up the wonderful work...I am hooked onto this...I started reading the first part a day ago, I haven't been able to do anything else but continue reading this wonderful fanfiction.

    And by the way, I gave my elder sister quite a scare, when I was reading that part when Legolas and Gilrion were out under Hadlir's protection, in the market...and those...those ABOMINATIONS almost cut his pretty golden hair... I really thought they were gonna do it and I went running all over the house like a mad person, yelling curses...

    Let's just say it scared the crap out of the other occupant of the house, lulz...

    Anyway, I am waiting patiently ::is lying:: for the next update...keep it going, you define everything a great writer should be!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - JuuJunRiki on October 17, 2009
    This is an amazing, simply amazing piece of work! I started with the Anestel, and I have barely been able to leave my laptop since! I love how wonderfully you have portrayed the characters and situations, as well as how wonderfully well written it is! I think you have an amazing storyline, and you have kept everything realistic,and to be honest, I can't stop reading! I was so excited that they were finally betrothed! Please keep writing and I can't wait to read the next bit!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - rick on September 30, 2009
    oh do write faster...this is so good.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - neerdua on September 29, 2009
    YES, YES, YES !!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Macheil on September 29, 2009
    Thanks for another chapter. I love this story!! I devour all updates...lol ....Macheil
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Alhena on September 24, 2009
    Why did you end it there???!!! I want to know what Legolas will say!
    Take care =D

    Love Cuil Eden
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aldariel on September 23, 2009
    Lovely job writing this story. Don't let the nay sayer change the direction of your story. You are doing a great job. Keep up the great writing.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Chronos Kitsune on September 14, 2009
    Ok, so I just read this whole story in two days and I think my brain might be overloaded with Glorfindel/Legolas (if such a thing is possible). I have to say, I LOVE this story. Not only is this the best Glorfindel/Legolas story I have ever read, I think it is definitely in the top three best LOTR stories I have ever read. Wonderful work so far and I can't wait to read the next chapter. (I almost let out a fangirl squeal when Glorfindel started his speech.)

    One more thing though: Don't get me wrong, I love the Lorien setting, but how much longer will it be before they return to Rivendell? (I'm starting to miss Elrond.)

    But anyways, like I said before, love the story so far and please update a.s.a.p.

    ~Chronos
    Report Review

  • From ANON - KittenEm on September 12, 2009
    I absolutely love this story! Your prose is beautifully written and your characters are very strong. Legolas and Glorifindel was wonderful together and I love how they have changed throughout the story. There was a very special moment for me in the last two chapters... when Legolas begged Glorfindel to wear his knots and even Glorfindel admits that he did it to shame him. It shows just how far these two characters have come together. I cannot wait to read more!

    PS- Legolas better say yes! lol
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Jo on September 09, 2009
    Okay, I'll try this again. I just wanted to say that the last chapter made me so happy I sent my dogs running to find out why I was screaming like a little girl...haha.
    Report Review

  • From Rihou101 on September 08, 2009
    I really love the story... not too fond of the cliff hangers but hey... it'll make me come back. ^_^ I'm even thinking of re-reading the whole story cause I love it so much.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lovely on September 02, 2009
    I really want him to say no. is that mean of me? I really like your story but I can't help but utterly hate glorifindel. it feels like stockholm sindrome. don't get me wrong; I love your story and the way it was written but Glorifindel is kind of sick... thanks for writing this chow!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!