rate_review Reviews

Haha, such a tease that Elladan! *bg* Still curious to see what is going to happen!

I just wanted to let you know how glad I am that you decided to post the Twilight Tales. I've been enjoying these brief snippets, but I hope this particular one won't be so brief. I've always been quite taken with Imrahil, even though there's so little of him in LOTR, and I was very disappointed when neither he nor the twins were in the movies. Well, now I can drool over him anyway! Thank you!

heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeey wait a second! I thought Elladan said he hadn't slept with anyone after meeting Nimethial!! (can't remember if that is her name...) Or wait...is this a definite AU from G&I?? ok then, you're forgiven. ~_^ MOOOOOOOORE!! I WANT MOOOOORE!! *snickers*

Oh, already I really *like* Imrahil Eresse! And I have a sneaking suspicion I'm even going to like Elladan in this one too! *wink* Seriously, I thought it may have been a little difficult, considering how much I loved your portrayal of Elrohir/Legolas in G&I to see past *that* pairing, but I can safely say that I don't think that's going to be a problem AT ALL. Which is not to say I wouldn't enjoy learning more about how they got together but I find myself more interested in Imrahil. He seems unaware of what his feelings for Elladan portend, actually quite disconnected from his Elven heritage as a whole. I like how perceptive he seems and his, I don't know modest? nature. Elladan will be able to teach him much I've no doubt! I also want to know more about *this* incarnation of Elladan because he feels very different to the G&I version you gave us. As I said, I don't think I'll have any problems investing in this story!

Standard request: update again soon. ~_^

Marie :-)

My first reaction was 'hmm...interesting!' and I am still thinking that *bg* So a multi-chapter part of the Twilight Tales, very interesting! So, keep on writing...really, I think I have said that in all my reviews, but it does seem to work! :)

I can understand why this tale would not fit in with G&I. But I like it nonetheless. Subtle slash has its own allure. I wonder if Elladan had come to Dol Amroth with Legolas and Elrohir at the time of Golden Obessen - n - father and son might have shared a mutual feeling of inrequited desire.

Yes! I love Imrahil, and I am so glad you wri writing him...I can't for for the next chapter! - Unless, of course, Imrahil's influence means Elladan will become mortal, in which case I will learn to hate him! ; )

I think I squealed with glee when I found that you are writing outakes to your previously brilliant stories!
I cannot wait to see how this one unfolds!
As always, your work is just fantastic and you do a far better job of the whole
thing than Tolkien himself *looks around nervously* I'll probably be hunted
down for saying that! *grin*
Keep up the GREAT work! Cannot wait for the next installment!

Elia
xxxx