rate_review Reviews

So this story was wonderful, heart-wrenching, beautiful and so unbelievably well written.

Your ending makes me want to take a shovel to your forehead.

Seriously.

I'm almost positive you're made of fleshy bits of pure evil mixed in with crazy talent.
Wonderful story, you're a fantastic writer. Hopefully I'll find a real ending to this story someday, though. I may cry otherwise. Thanks for the great read.

You left many questions open, I hope there will be another part of this story?
I loved to read this and I just wnat to know, if Glorfindel an Thranduil can heal Erestors soul. Please write another part. One reader you will surely have.

I hope we will read us again.

Until then.
Best regards,
Naduah

When I started reading this story, I didn't know if I would enjoy it. I was so very wrong. From the first chapter to the last, I have loved this story. I hope a sequel is soon to follow!

Oh, why did you stop in this moment? That isn't fair! ;-) I just wnat to know, if elrond is able to help Erestor.

I love this story (I think, I did alraedy say this, didn't I?) I just want to beat Authon, because he ignored Erestor bounderies and didn't respect the safeword. Your discription were so real, I sometimes had to remind me, that this is a fanfiction.

I know, it was just a short review, but I can't say all I want in English.

So, I hope the next chapter will come soon.

Best regard, Naduah.

Hello,

I must say, I love this story. The feelings of your charas are discribed very well and I suffer with your Charas. In the last chapter, I was also suprised, that Legolas stayed, but I think, the twins performed great.

I love the story about Erestor and Glorfindel and I hope, Erestor will tell Glorfindel the truth about his foretime.

Please forgive me my bad English, but this language isn't my native.

So, I can't await the next chapter. Please don't let us wait for long.

Best regards,
Naduah

Really liking this story. Very dark and angsty. So intrigued to find out who Erestor's mysterious phantom is.