Click Here!

Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name

By : Celesta
  • From ANON - jw on July 12, 2005
    Good God it's about time. Well I hope to God Asca doens't lose the baby in the fight she has with Thranduil. Legolas would never forgive his ada then. And let's hope that Thranduil allows her to have her say.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jasmine on July 11, 2005
    Love the story. I can just see how nervis Rose would be about meeting her father-in-law. Love the way you did the cliff hanger. Sometimes men just have to be left wanting.

    Please write more soon

    Jasmine
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MarzBar on July 11, 2005
    Thank you so much for the latest chapter. We will be waiting for her meeting with Thranduil and relocation to Mirkwood. In the last chapter you had Galadriel say something about Rose belonging to the race of men when I thought it would say did NOT belong to the race of men. OK, that's my nitpick. More soon please.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Margaret Longstreth on May 08, 2005
    I just found this story and read it straight through. I love the idea and am so happy that Legolas found someone (even though it's not me). I am not surprised that she is pregnant and I do hope that you will not do the movie and kill the arrogant but gorgeous March Warden. How soon are you going to tell us what her real role is to be since Galadriel welcomed her home? I hope you are feeling better and will give us more soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on May 06, 2005
    OMG! I am sooooo sorry about what happened. Get well soon and update as soon as you can.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on February 28, 2005
    Where the hell have you been? It's been five months since you last updated. What happened? Please update soon or post an author's note. I realyl want to know where this fic is going.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on January 05, 2005
    *taps fingeres impatiently on the desk, pauses and looks at watch then calendar* Ai! Valar! Where are you girl? It's been three, nearly four months since you've updated. *SIGHS* Oh well I'll just have to wait then. Update soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Spring on October 11, 2004
    I love your story. It has interested me since the beginning and it continues to have me waiting anxiously for the next chapter. I especially like the Asca/Haldir interaction as well as her interaction with the fellowship. I apologize for not reviewing before but I thought it required an account on the website.

    Can I persuade you to give me a sneak peek at the next chapter? I check just about every day for updates for your story so I was kindof hoping for a preview. Sigh. Well keep writing, I shall never get enough of this story.

    Have a good day,
    Spring
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yue on September 16, 2004
    OHH ANOTHER UPDATE!!! LUV YA!!! *jumps up and does a party dance while little sis's looking at me like im the next candadate for entering the asylem* Oh yeah..! *holds up hands in an im innocent pose* Asca's obsesiveness over the robe is none of my doing and if any wereing is visable in the near future its her fault for over usage. but just between u and me (and the others that are goin to read my review), asca's not gonna get a chance to were the robe down if u get my drift. *a bucket is suddenenly sent sailing 35MPH towards my head and connects.*

    asca: if u so much as inhale in my room....... * starts yelling about mutalation and/or torture sessions that shes goin to *

    *

    yue:...........................@o@..........................*unable to reply due to a concussion. twitch, twitch*


    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on August 29, 2004
    *snaps fingers in air and does happy dance* I KNEW IT! Asca's was pregnant. Love her introduction to Elrond. Can't wait to see if she sends a note along with Haldir to give to Legolas when he leaves fro Helms Deep or if she sneaks off herself. Legolas is going to be thrilled at the news about Asca being pregnant. Wasn't Gandalf supposed to be in Lothlorien fro a couple days after he was resurrected before meeting with Merry and Pippin, then joining up with Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli?

    Update soon chica! You have me on the edge of my seat now.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on August 07, 2004
    Welcome back to the land of the living. Where have you been and why havne't you updated in a month? I wanna know if I was right in guessing that Asca was pregnant? Please update more often I love this fic, very well written and I love the interaction she has with the main characters.

    Legolas her hubby, Aragorn and Boromir the loving older borthers she never had, the hobbits the younger brothers she never had, Gandalf her grandfather, Gimli an uncle, Celeborn and Galadriel treat her as if she were another daughter, Rumil and Orophin treat her like a sister as well. Haldir, now that's a challenge but I get the impression he's going to end being like the annoying older brother.

    I wonder how Asca's giong to take the news of Boromir's death and how is Thrandruil going to take the fact that Legolas 'married' a mortal? Please update more often, at least once a week, please please please pretty please with a hot fudge sundae on top.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on August 07, 2004
    Welcome back to the land of the living. Where have you been and why havne't you updated in a month? I wanna know if I was right in guessing that Asca was pregnant? Please update more often I love this fic, very well written and I love the interaction she has with the main characters.

    Legolas her hubby, Aragorn and Boromir the loving older borthers she never had, the hobbits the younger brothers she never had, Gandalf her grandfather, Celeborn and Galadriel treat her as if she were another daughter, Rumid Ord Orophin treat her like a sister as well. Haldir, now that's a challenge but I get the impression he's going to end being like the annoying older brother.

    I wonder how Asca's giong to take the news of Boromir's death and how is Thrandruil going to take the fact that Legolas 'married' a mortal? Please update more often, at least once a week, please please please pretty please with a hot fudge sundae on top.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sister Kitty on August 06, 2004
    YESSSSSSSSSS

    Another installment. I was worrying whether you were alright.

    Love it, but as usual I wish there was more of it!

    Carry on, I love it!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yue on August 05, 2004
    another chapter!!!! bring out the champaign bottles!!!! yeah!!!! by the way great chapt. im so thursty for another chapter. poor girl, having to put up with a dislikeful haldir everyday. i feel sorry for the heroine everytime she's reminded of legolas by his clothing and such. i also absolutely love the idea of her wearing his robe. * tries to make a grab for said robe but ascodhaldil kicks me in the stomach, sending me flying to the other side of the room. Craws back to the keyboard* cough cough. anywayz. lets forget about the robe until next time * heroine glares at me, and i cring* maybe not...... oh yes. i also like to say that i've found a lot of grammer and spelling errors in this chapter. if u need someone to proof read it i'll galdly do it if u want. well its late and i'll go get ready to steal legolas's robe * heroine pulls out a double edge s* i * i mean i'll go get ready to sleep. hope u get the next chapter out soon. night.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Miriellar on July 02, 2004
    I was sooo glad to see that you've updated- it's been so long! Anyways- it's been such a long time that I've read a story that I've enjoyed as much as this. Please update soon!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!