Click Here!

Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name

By : Celesta
  • From ANON - xoulblade on February 08, 2004
    LOL Too bad Hally doesnt end up with a black eye..............but he needs to get laid....OR a human girl can stumble (literally) on him, too bad Asca doesnt have a younger sister ooo *hinthint* (then he can get some) Like what his brothers told Leggy and Asca...okay I'll shut up but I love this chapter cant wait until the next one, Ja ne!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - xoulblade on February 08, 2004
    LOL Too bad Hally doesnt end up with a black eye..............but he needs to get laid....OR a human girl can stumble (literally) on him, too bad Asca doesnt have a younger sister ooo *hinthint* (then he can get some) Like what his brothers told Leggy and Asca...okay I'll shut up but I love this chapter cant wait until the next one, Ja ne!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - tlstroud on February 07, 2004
    I Love it, Love it, Love it. Please write more and soon.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on February 05, 2004
    And thus is proven the old adage "Never say never" ^__^ Hee, I like Celeborn now. But what was Galadriel hinting about with the dress... *shifty look* Ok, more!! Please, I wanna be spoiled :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - DragonEyeZ on February 05, 2004
    FINALLY!!! *dances* Haldir got what he deserved!

    Anyway, lovely chapter, lovely story! I't 't wait for next installment. :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on February 05, 2004
    LOL, Haldir got b#$%^ slapped and he got told where to stick it. I am wholeheartedly in agreement with Asca about the way Haldir's been acting. He really needs to be told how she was treated. IF he had been told after their first confrontation I doubt he would have treated that way. Also the way he spoke was not the way someone should treat a person of Royalty.

    Please tell me that subtle hint that Galadriel gave Asca means that she’s pregnant. You know the following scene:



    I know that's what you mean isn't it, *cat-that-ate-the-canary-grin on face*. btw Thanks for the reply.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - sisterkitty on February 05, 2004
    Yippeee - a new installment

    Please please let Haldir have a little bit more comeuppance - I want to see him grovel!!!!!!!

    Thank you
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NightStrider on February 04, 2004
    my friend i shall have to kill you now. you should no better than to just leave us all here hanging overyvery thin legde as to what is going to happen next. shame on you. yet i must admit that i do enjoy cliffhangers. so no worries. i did enjoy the name calling on Ascadholiel's part. Haldir should get his thick head out of his ass. no offense to any fans of Haldirs' just a statement. i really want to know what it was that Legolas and Galadriel spoke of. omy cmy curiosity runs wild now. thank you for your fantastic writting.

    how long must we all wait to see the next chapter??
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cait on February 03, 2004
    Good chapter. What did Galadriel say to Legolas? *curious!!*
    Update soon. Later
    Report Review

  • From ANON - xoulblade on February 03, 2004
    see Im reviewing! :D Anyway Im enjoying your story, I write too, if you want to you can read some of mine, they are on FF.net, under the penname, xoulblade. My favorite elf is Haldir and Legolas, but mostly Hally. I cant wait until the next chapter.........*whispers* your story isn't a Mary-Sue...........believe me, I have read them and yours isn't one of them!
    ~_^
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on February 03, 2004
    LOL, I am soo in agreement with the way that Asca told Haldir off. Once he finds out how she was treated (if he ever does find out) by her father and ex he will most likely apologize. And I like her reaction when she finds out that she is now a Princess and Legolas oh-so-conviently forgot to tell her after they were 'married'. I think it's goign to be worse when he tells her about the immortality bit. Can't wait to read more.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sister Kitty on February 03, 2004
    Love it - one of the first stops every morning when I get to work is to check if there is a new chapter!!!!

    Thank you I love the character interplay and how you have been able to add to the story without making it seam too way out!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on February 02, 2004
    Poor Hladir, getting cussed out by an injured human woman. Then stumbling. All while other people are watching. I bet his brothers will never let him live it down... *shakes head* I can't believe it took you two weeks!! Oh well, it was still pretty good ^__^ I do hope the next update doesn't take as long...?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NightStrider on January 21, 2004
    Celesta, oh my god. you did such a great job writting Chapters 9 and 10. very nice!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Drea on January 21, 2004
    This is a great story so far. I hope you wright some more. Good luck writing :)!!!!!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!