Click Here!

Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name

By : Celesta
  • From ANON - NightStrider on January 21, 2004
    hey ech chapter seems to get better and better. her rants are quiet amusing. keep it up!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on January 20, 2004
    .....o____O I am afraid. *glares at brain* Bad! Better start working again before I stop feeling nice-- wait. I wasn't feeling nice. *whips out Spatula of Doom* Work. Now.

    Haldir is such an ass, ne? Ah well, in a loveable sort of way... maybe. I shall shut up now.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NightStrider on January 20, 2004
    Celesta, this is very good. i really enjoy the fact that you seemed to have control of characters character. if that makes any sense. you have done a fantastic job!!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From on January 19, 2004
    this is such a good story
    please write more
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cait on January 19, 2004
    Ill show ur brain what's good for it if ya want. lol
    Poor Gandalf. It's good there in lothlorien now. Will she look into the mirror? hehe
    Update soon. Type quickly! later.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cindy on January 19, 2004
    This is a really great story,I love it! A few parts were sad enough to bring tears to my eyes, but over all it's a well thought out well written story. More soon,please?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Elerrina Rose on January 16, 2004
    Yay! Lothlorien next! Lothlorien next!
    Lemme guess... she's gonna tell off Haldir, right? heh heh heh... oooooooooh, this is going to be fantastic.
    If this was a different kind of fic, I'd be looking forward to a good spanking for the marchwarden *wink* but a toungue lashing will suit me just fine :)
    Lovely. The bonding and aftermath with the others was handled so well. Wonderful, Bravissimo.
    Eagerly awaiting more,
    ~ Elerrina Rose
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sisiter Kitty on January 16, 2004
    Right on girl keep it coming I am much enjoying reading your story while at work - it gives a nice break and makes me forget how shitty it is here at the moment.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on January 16, 2004
    Wow... running with major blood loss. Braver than me, that's for sure.

    Wheee, update soon! Need more fluff... *turns into a fluff-starved zombie*
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Serenityk200k2000 on January 15, 2004
    Good Good Good Good! It's all good. Now I have the urge to watch Fellowship of the Ring! And watch it I shall!

    And as I am watching it I will be pictureing Asca in there also!

    As always (Greedy for more!) *rubbing hands together excitedly*

    SB
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jw on January 15, 2004
    Celesta,

    First of all I think this a great story. You did a wonderful job of integrating her into the fellowship. And do not pay any attention to those that say it was too soon. According to the book it took the fellowship 1 1/2 weeks to get from Rivendell to Carhadras and another 1 12-2 weeks to get from Carhadras to Lothlorien. I am assuming She was with them for t 3-t 3-6 days before she and Legolas 'married'. If she was mostly talking with Legolas during the walking (since he was carrying her) then of course they'd get to know each other better and some people can just tell they can completely trust others.

    As for her chewing out Boromir, she apologized as well. And I do not know any woman from our time taking that kind of talk from any body. I think it is good that she is able to trust the guys so much as to tell them about her abusive father and ex-boyfriend. It is good to vent and share. It's healthy. And might I add 'You go Legolas' when he said, "There will be much blood spilt." I don't think he's ever been that angry. 'IF' her b^$!#% of a father and a$$^@!& of an ex-boyfriend show up they are going to have some very angry people ready to do them a world of hurt. *evil laugh*

    It seems to me like the hobbits, Aragorn, and Boromir are acting like brothers (the hobbits are the younger with Aragorn and Boromir the older) and Gandalf is her fatherly or is it grandfatherly figure. Gimli's role right now is more of a good friend. Please update soon. I have really enjoyed the story so far. I can't wait to see her reaction to Galadriel in that chapter.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AzureDragoness on January 14, 2004
    Yay for citrus goodness! Just cause she gets the elf doesn't make it Mary-Sue; it just makes it every het woman's fantasy ^__^ Thanks for spoiling us so with such a long chappie! Want more now....
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on January 14, 2004
    "Aquiest your Request" Is that from Pirates of the Carribean??? I personally love that movie.

    Your "Lemon" was not so sour. I certainly have writen worse and read worse. I think you handled it quite well. And as for Aragon giving his blessin, well damn he should since he himself is holding the heart of one fair elvish princess.

    This fic is getting better and better. Please send more my way

    SB
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Elerrina Rose on January 14, 2004
    EEEE!!!!! So happy! It continues to be fabulous! Ahhhhhh!!! I'm simply thrilled with this turn of events :)
    Hooray! Very well written.
    Asca and Legs are so wonderful together that I must keep reminding myself that they met only a few days ago. Wonderful! Yay!
    I am just BURSTING to see what comes next!!! eeeeeeeee!!!!!!
    Much appreciation,
    ~ Elerrina Rose
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Drucilynda on January 14, 2004
    Great story,
    Many try to create a love story with Legolas and wind up making it just pure smut. The "lemon" scene was done tastefully, and the story is mushy, but not corny. I am enjoying it thoroughly. Please update me when you post again.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!