Click Here!

Reviews for Cuil Eden

By : Esteliel
  • From ANON - Anita on December 04, 2003
    The only thing I have to say is...Oh oh! This really frustrating since I have no idea how Glorfindel will respond; will he become angry at Elrond (or even Legolas) or will he join in or will he start laughing, adding to Legolas' humiliation, and then thake the elf with him or....I don't know!
    I'll just wait for the next chapter.

    ps: and Elrond is unpredictable as well!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nimue on December 03, 2003
    That was the most brint cnt cliffhanger ever conceived. Bravo!

    I've been following this story since the beginning, and have always been lazylazy to leave a review. This is the next best thing, though not even a proper review. But then, as I have nothing to critique, what can I say? Please take this as a message of support and adoration, or, at the very least, a means of inspiration. You have a HUGE audience on various lists and archives. I wish you the best in your writing endeavors, and staving off the ever presensnt fear of writer's block. May your muse's treat you well.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - m on December 03, 2003
    oh, you do love hearing the screams as your readers fall over the edge of the cliff, don't you.

    such an interesting story. Elrond is going to make Glorfindel acknowledge Legolas, isn't he?

    Keep on writing!
    Report Review

  • From Iamme on December 03, 2003
    OK! That was a nasty cliffie! I need more !!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Exrated on December 03, 2003
    Omg, omg, omg, omg, I LOVE IT! That must be the best chapter in this story, I just ADORE the ending! I've probably reread the last paragraph six times in a row before reviewing, and it's amazing! Ouuuu... Glorfindel... how will he react!?!?!? Eee! Now I can't wait for the next chapter...... omg omg omg! Sorry if this sounds like random non-sense, I'm in a state of joyfull shock. O_O

    Please, please, please try to get the next chapter up quickly or I'll just die! I've officy bey become obsessed with the s.

    .

    Cheers!

    Obsessivly, X
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tinni on December 03, 2003
    Okay, what the hell is going on?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ArchNemesis on November 30, 2003
    What is Lord Elrond up to? Glorfindel seemed put out at his lord's suggestion but that made Legolas happy that he's spending more time with him and their son.
    Excellent work! Please update soon!

    Nemesis ^_~
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tinni on November 30, 2003
    Nice, next chapter soon please.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NOne on November 24, 2003
    Aww...cliffhangers! I have been following your story for quite some time now, and I am very impressed with your work. I do not review much, but I feel you deserve such. Please keep up the good work, your story is wonderfull! =-)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Milly on November 22, 2003
    On Legolas: Well just to say it clearly: I'ld cry if he leaves Glorfindel or the other way round. Instead I would like to see him become more like Glorfindel's lover and less like his possession. I can't seriously see Legolas suddenly want to have a female lover, that would disappoint me seriously and make me consider whether this stories are still my favs. But I count on your taste like I always did, Esteliel, and I'm sure I'll love the next chap just like I loved this one and the one before and...
    On Glorfindel: I *hope* that your beloved Glorfindel will be careful enough to make sure that he doesn't *seriously* hurt Legolas.
    On Elrond: He seems worried about my poor precious Elrohir. *sighs deeply* Let's hope he'll make the best decisions for his well-being.
    On Estor: He is surely just misunderstood!!! Please remember that I'm craving to see Erestor/Elrohir. *blushes*
    On the twins: Hm... I fear for Elrohir in Mirkwood after what Elladan did to Celeirdúr in Imladris. *winces*

    @Esteliel: You know that I love your stories dearly, thanks for writing them, please go on as soon as you find the time for it!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tinni on November 22, 2003
    I wonder what Elrond has for Legolas. Please don't put Erestor together with Elrohir, it would be cooler if Elrohir falls for a Sinda. Erestor iis sis story is just such an ass.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Brin on November 22, 2003
    What! What has he got for him??? Oh, you dirty bird, LOL!
    Waiting and wanting more, please!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Aly on November 21, 2003
    That was a cruel place to leave off!! Please, with that lead in, don't let it be as long before your next update! I can't wait to find out what Elrond has for Legolas, and what the rest of the meeting will involve.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Calenharn Elflover on November 06, 2003
    To: a reader....

    I agree with everything that you wrote, except the last part - the bit about Legolas finding a woman. lol! I personally am hoping that Legolas will start to find his spine before he becomes proficient in weapons (which has a long learning curve) - preferably to some extent once Elrond starts laying down his edicts and mandating better behavior towards Legolas (at least in public).

    Please join us in the ongoing discussion and speculation over at the LoM BBS:
    http://depresso-girl.com/libraryofmoria/viewtopic.php?t=30 :)

    Report Review

  • From ANON - A reader on November 05, 2003
    Although this story derives its charm exactly because Legolas is so submisive and Glorfindel dominant, I am personally beginning to feel angry at Legolas' lack of backbone. I understand that psychologically that's how humiliated victims act, but... that's not the Legolas we all know and love. I'd like Legolas to rebel at some point, to understand his individual value and rights and break free from his enslavement. To stand up to Glorfindel, to rise to his full height and say "no, I'm not your toy". I think that that kind of strength will come through his fighting lessons, he will become confident and independent. He will stop being a frightened child and become a self-assured adult. As for Glorfindel... well I'd like to see his eyes pop out from surprise at Legolas' rebellion and understand that he's not the master anymore. And... well... no offense to slash, but I'd like Legolas to know the love of a woman in the end and though that to say goodbye to his abusive past. Just my humble opinion. :) Keep writing! :)
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!